LESSWRONG
LW

Wikitags

Rationalist Taboo

Edited by Vladimir_Nesov, TheAncientGeek, John_Maxwell, et al. last updated 2nd Oct 2020

Rationalist Taboo is a technique for fighting muddles in discussions. By prohibiting the use of a certain word and all the words synonymous to it, people are forced to elucidate the specific contextual meaning they want to express, thus removing ambiguity otherwise present in a single word.

Mainstream philosophy has a parallel procedure called "unpacking". Unpacking has the requirement that the contentious or doubtful term be expanded out--not just replaced with a synonym--and only used as a collection of subcomponent concepts.

Main Posts

  • Taboo Your Words
  • Replace the Symbol with the Substance

Other Posts

  • Disputing Definitions - An example of how the technique helps.
  • Words as Hidden Inferences - The mere presence of words can influence thinking, sometimes misleading it.
  • Detached Lever Fallacy - There is a lot of machinery hidden beneath the words, and rationalist's taboo is one way to make a step towards exposing it.
Subscribe
3
Subscribe
3
Discussion0
Discussion0
Posts tagged Rationalist Taboo
293Taboo Your Words
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
133
351Taboo "Outside View"
Daniel Kokotajlo
4y
33
119Disputing Definitions
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
46
66Tabooing "Frame Control"
Raemon
2y
41
99Words as Hidden Inferences
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
23
93Replace the Symbol with the Substance
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
17
92Detached Lever Fallacy
Eliezer Yudkowsky
17y
43
59Avoid Contentious Terms
jefftk
4y
6
55The Technique Taboo
lsusr
6y
43
31Take 8: Queer the inner/outer alignment dichotomy.
Ω
Charlie Steiner
3y
Ω
2
28Taboo "rationality," please.
MBlume
16y
54
27Work harder on tabooing "Friendly AI"
ChrisHallquist
13y
52
21In favor of tabooing the word “values” and using only “priorities” instead
chaosmage
7y
11
6Tabooing Science + an xkcd comic about the eclipse - "Honestly, it's not that scientific."
Voltairina
8y
3
1Steelmanning as an alternative to Rationalist Taboo
[anonymous]8y
2
Load More (15/27)
Add Posts