leaving only a TM computation, you have abstracted away an essential ingredient of consciousness.
I think I can see a rube/blegg situation here.
A TM computation perfectly modelling a human brain (let's say) but without any real-time interaction, and a GLUT, represent the two ways in which we can have one of 'intelligent input-output' and 'functional organization isomorphic to that of an intelligent person' without the other.
What people think they mean by 'consciousness' - a kind of 'inner light' which is either present or not - doesn't (straightforwardly) correspond to anything that objectively exists. When we hunt around for objective properties that correlate with places where we think the 'inner light' is shining, we find that there's more than one candidate. Both 'intelligent input-output' and the 'intelligent functional organization' pick out exactly those beings we believe to be conscious - our fellow humans foremost among them. But in the marginal cases where we have one but not the other, I don't think there is a 'further fact' about whether 'real consciousness' is present.
However, we do face the 'further question' of how much moral value to assign in the marginal cases - should we feel guilty about switching off a simulation that no-one is looking at? Should we value a GLUT as an 'end in itself' rather than simply a means to our ends? (The latter question isn't so important given that GLUTs can't exist in practice.)
I wonder if our intuition that the physical facts underdetermine the answers to the moral questions is in some way responsible for the intuition of a mysterious non-physical 'extra fact' of whether so-and-so is conscious. Perhaps not, but there's definitely a connection.
... we do face the 'further question' of how much moral value to assign ...
Yes, and I did not even attempt to address that 'further question' because it seems to me that that question is at least an order of magnitude more confused than the relatively simple question about consciousness.
But, if I were to attempt to address it, I would begin with the lesson from Econ 101 that dissolves the question "What is the value of item X?". The dissolution begins by requesting the clarifications "Value to whom?" and "Valuable in what conte... (read more)
You all know the rules: