All of Steve_Omohundro's Comments + Replies

Pascal's Mugging: Tiny Probabilities of Vast Utilities

Very interesting thought experiment!

One place where it might fall down is that our disutility for causing deaths is probably not linear in the number of deaths, just as our utility for money flattens out as the amount gets large. In fact, I could imagine that its value is connected to our ability to intuitively grasp the numbers involved. The disutility might flatten out really quickly so that the disutility of causing the death of 3^^^^3 people, while large, is still small enough that the small probabilities from the induction are not overwhelmed by it.

2DanielLC11yThat just means you have to change the experiment. Suppose he just said he'll cause a certain amount of net disutility, without specifying how. This works unless you assume a maximum possible disutility.