All of thomascolthurst's Comments + Replies

Prior work, in the form of a twitter joke:  https://twitter.com/thomascolthurst/status/1032345388605431810

I answer the "why are trees so tall" question at http://whirledofideas.blogspot.com/2015/05/why-are-trees-tall.html .  The rough answer is that height limiting treaties need to be enforced, and enforcement is costly, and for the most obvious enforcement mechanism that trees have available (negative allelopathy), enforcement is not observable by other trees.  So if any trees did enforce a height limiting treaty, the trees that freeloaded on their enforcement would out-compete them, and that's why we see tall trees and not height-treaty-limited trees.

3Viliam3y
Praise our lord Moloch for giving us trees in which shades we can rest!

There is a large existing literature on pruning neural networks, starting with the 1990 paper "Optimal Brain Damage" by Le Cun, Denker and Solla. A recent paper with more references is https://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.03635.pdf

Especially for the study of consciousness and mental states, I associate this useful tactic with Daniel Dennett's term "heterophenomenology".

9Said Achmiz5y
I also thought of heterophenomenology when reading this. (It is, I think, quite a useful concept, and it would be good if someone wrote an LW post explaining it. I will do it at some point, if no one else gets there first.)

FYI, there are published counterexamples to Cox's theorem. See for example Joseph Halpern's at http://arxiv.org/pdf/1105.5450.pdf.

0Vaniver10y
You need to not include the period in your link, like so.

Perfect descriptions of reality are unattainable, unnecessary, and too costly for learning organisms, including humans. But workable descriptions are indispensable. So knowledge systems, like maps, are a complex blend of realism, flexibility, usefulness, and inspiration.

-- David Christian, Maps of Time: An Introduction to Big History

Someone once quoted Shakespeare to the philosopher W. V. O. Quine: "There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy." To which Quine is said to have responded: "Possibly, but my concern is that there not be more things in my philosophy than are in heaven and earth."

Reported by Chet Raymo

1simplicio14y
The perfect reply to that, my least favourite line of Shakespeare.

Hi. I'm Thomas Colthurst. I will be doing a visiting fellowship at the Singularity Institute this summer.