LESSWRONG
LW

1510
Stuff I found online
AIPractical
Personal Blog

25

Metaphor.systems

by the gears to ascension
21st Dec 2022
1 min read
9

25

This is a linkpost for https://metaphor.systems/

25

Previous:
[link, 2019] AI paradigm: interactive learning from unlabeled instructions
No comments2 karma
Next:
Stop Talking to Each Other and Start Buying Things: Three Decades of Survival in the Desert of Social Media
14 comments1 karma
Log in to save where you left off
Metaphor.systems
4plex
4tricky_labyrinth
6the gears to ascension
3the gears to ascension
2the gears to ascension
2the gears to ascension
2the gears to ascension
2the gears to ascension
2the gears to ascension
New Comment
9 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 9:40 PM
[-]plex3y40

I used Metaphor to find many entries on the upcoming map of AI safety.

Reply
[-]tricky_labyrinth3y40

Just for calibration, what are the other things you've tried? I've tried alternative search engines like https://millionshort.com, link aggregators/curators like reddit/slashdot/hackernews/etc, manually curated lists.

(I've been playing around with it for a bit and it seems quite good to me too)

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y60

in my workflow, the ranking had been, in order of what I try first to answer a question, text-davinci-2, ddg, kagi, google, millionshort, teclis, with a diversion to youtube if I needed a visual explanation of something. I'd go straight for ddg or google if trying to get a specific result, and that hasn't changed with introduction of metaphor.systems. text-davinci-3 pushes further up the list; I'm more likely to ask it a question now, but not massively so. meanwhile, metaphor near entirely replaced kagi and teclis and also usually google, I'm back to google for exact-result queries except when google refuses to give multiple word sense interpretations in which case I open ddg, and sometimes I ask text-davinci-3 for help figuring out what I'm looking for. I usually use metaphor first. I have it set as my default search. the different query format it needs sometimes takes multiple tries, but once I find a good search, I get incredible results I've never seen another tool match, not even text-davinci-3 or chatgpt.

chatgpt didn't enter my workflow. the rlhf flavor it has makes it too hard to use and it gives overly verbose responses.

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y30

https://metaphor.systems/search?q=this is one of the most cost efficient and effective constructive community focused on the ground organizations I've found in any of the leftist%2C anarchist or charity communities worldwide%3A

some results, not closely examined for quality, but all high enough quality to be clearly worth a consideration:

  • https://foodnotbombs.net/new_site/
  • https://mutualaiddisasterrelief.org/
  • https://www.foodnotlawns.com/
  • https://workersdefensealliance.org/
  • https://fnbtac.org/
  • https://www.frontlinewellness.org/
  • https://www.altruistrelief.org/
  • https://www.twincitieslogistics.org/
  • https://foodnotbombsatl.org/
  • https://www.givewell.org/
  • https://www.brcaid.org/
  • https://lavamaex.org/
  • https://itsgoingdown.org/building-around-mutual-aid-programs/
  • https://www.rosehipmedics.org/
  • https://linktr.ee/RedSleevesACA
  • https://www.publicassistants.org/
  • https://www.neighborhoodaction.info/

also has interesting results if you substitute "worldwide" for your own location. eg, this same query has interesting results for the bay area in particular. lots of overlap, couple more pages of good results, but here are some non-overlapping results:

  • https://eastbayfoodnotbombs.org/
  • https://restoreoakland.org/
  • https://www.quicc.org/
  • https://www.place.community/
  • https://www.self-sufficiency.org/
  • https://www.shelteroak.org/
Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y20

I used metaphor to find a bunch of suggestions for how to improve community coprotection in the face of adversarial behavior from community members: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/WmscKHmyZvuRg48HL/women-and-effective-altruism?commentId=shncEPGboY7s9JXPx

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y20

I used metaphor to find the results I gave for this question answer: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/nZBfpwRnZ63xF67hQ/is-there-some-reason-llms-haven-t-seen-broader-use?commentId=hnP3kyAWrcm3X8Z9K - I don't remember what query I used there, but paste any link from those into metaphor and you'll get a really nice similarity search you can use to browse for more.

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y20

commentary on a "synthesizing cooperation plans" post, discussing what queries I'd use to find related work (very good post, by the way!) https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/HbPXiB5Aiv3uHPXEh/master-plan-spec-needs-audit-logic-and-cooperative-ai?commentId=9AtA2LkgKzrf4SCqz

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y20

another example I gave was in response to a call for reliable link quality tagging; there are many projects to find reliable link tagging. the original comment - some of my queries in that comment are rather long: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/NLm7QEzFfTRq252My/reestablishing-reliable-sources-a-system-for-tagging-urls?commentId=jN5HJLwcEbFkZf6Be

Reply
[-]the gears to ascension3y20

I used it to make a list a few days ago of existing safety benchmarks, in response to a prompt for such things being posted: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/KQ6fGiPeMnzzC6p9q/race-to-the-top-benchmarks-for-ai-safety?commentId=A7FMZpfHgjRFHCcCq

Reply
Moderation Log
More from the gears to ascension
View more
Curated and popular this week
9Comments
AIPractical
Personal Blog

https://metaphor.systems has been absolutely incredible for finding new things on the internet. It hands-down beats every other site I've tried, including some of the ones you'd think of when I say something like that. I'm going to put some examples in the comments over the next day or so asynchronously, please add your own as well.

please vote up or down the examples you find most useful, and provide an example or two of your own if you come up with anything particularly good. there's also a discord server where people can share prompts, though those prompts are usually not as effective as mine, and I haven't been sharing mine there much.

You can also use metaphor to do a similarity search for any url. The results can sometimes be a bit samey, but often it's good for finding more services like a given service.

my single favorite site I've found on metaphor so far is microsolidarity.cc