You're standing at a crossroads, genuinely unsure which path to take. Information flows through your mind in the form of memories, projections, and conflicting desires. The deliberation feels like something. There's a distinctive texture to weighing options, to the gradual crystallization of preference, to the moment you finally decide.

This feeling seems undeniable. Yet its relationship to the physical firing of neurons in your brain remains deeply puzzling. Why doesn't all this information processing happen "in the dark," without any inner felt quality? This is what philosopher David Chalmers called the "hard problem" of consciousness, and it's supposedly the deepest mystery in science.

I think the hard problem is asking the wrong question. And I think I can show you why.

The Problem with "Why?"

Current theories of consciousness (Integrated Information Theory, Global Workspace Theory, Predictive Processing) all identify impressive neural mechanisms. They map correlates, explain functions, predict behaviors. But they all leave the same gap: why should these mechanisms feel like anything?

Even if we perfectly understood every neuron, every oscillation, every information flow, we'd still face the question: but why does it feel like something? The theories identify what consciousness correlates with, but not why the correlation exists.

Here's my claim: this question is malformed. It's like asking "why is water wet?" before understanding molecular chemistry. The question presupposes that "wetness" is something added to H₂O molecules, some extra property that needs explaining. But wetness isn't added to molecular structure, it is what that molecular structure feels like from the perspective of macroscopic tactile interaction.

Once you understand the chemistry, there's no remaining mystery about wetness. There's just molecules doing what molecules do, and wetness is what that is at the scale of human touch. And I think consciousness works the same way.

The Five Conditions

Let me propose something specific. Phenomenal consciousness, that is, the subjective experience of "what it's like" to be you, emerges when a system satisfies five conditions simultaneously:

1. Class 4 Computational Dynamics

Your brain doesn't run on lookup tables. It doesn't follow simple formulas. It exhibits what Stephen Wolfram calls "Class 4" computation: deterministic but computationally irredu...

Posts

Wikitag Contributions

Comments