Summary (TL;DR): Current AI safety discourse relies on the internalization of ethics—a premise that collapses as AI moves toward autonomous execution. This post argues that ethics can only function if it is a structural requirement, not an optional guideline. I propose SYMloop as the minimal architecture necessary to ensure human meaning-making remains an unbypassable circuit in the loop of autonomous systems.

Introduction: Ethics Can No Longer Function on "Goodwill"

The rapid evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is undermining the long-held assumption of "control through ethics." In an era where AI was merely a tool to assist human decision-making, ethical principles and guidelines acted as a sufficient deterrent. However, as AI transitions into an autonomous agent capable of continuous execution, this premise collapses.

Ethics only functions when humans have the space to "pause and question meaning." Yet, the speed, scale, and irreversibility of autonomous AI leave no such room. Consequently, ethics—while still discussed as a "noble ideal"—is being pushed outside the actual structure of execution.

This paper treats the problem not as a moral deficiency ("lack of ethics"), but as a structural failure where ethical judgment cannot ignite. I propose SYMloop (Symbiotic Meaning Loop) as the sole structural condition for making human ethical judgment a reality in the age of autonomous AI.

Chapter 1: The Dysfunction of Ethics in the AI Era

1.1 Ethics is a "Condition for Execution," Not Just a Premise for Judgment Ethics traditionally requires three implicit conditions:

The deciding subject is human.
There is cognitive and temporal space for judgment.
The judgment result is reflected in the action.

Autonomous AI erodes all of these. In a world where judgment and execution are decoupled, and execution completes before judgment can catch up, ethics is relegated to a mere post-hoc evaluation.

1.2 Why "Ethical Guidelines" Fail Current AI safety discourse relies on codifying ethical principles or internal safety constraints. These all assume a human or a model that chooses to follow them. For malicious actors or systems prioritizing speed, ethics is merely a "bypassable constraint." The structure that allows ethics to be optional is what has already failed.

Chapter 2: Ethics Can Only Be Enforced by Structure

In a social system, ethics must be designed as an unavoidable mechani...

Posts

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Posts

Wikitag Contributions

Comments