As a new user, it's hard to know where to start, and how to contribute to a community. being a Good Samaritan by nationality, I was reading through the guides and posts pertaining to the LessWrong community. One article that stood out to me is the "Well-Kept Gardens Die By Pacifism" post. The rhetoric revolves around the fool, and where the fool goes, (intellectual) communities die. It resonated with me. I manage a community that's large on paper, but in practice often devoid of content that excites experts. Indeed, now devoid of the content that attracted (and was made by) the experts that grew the community in the first place, long before... (read 1679 more words →)
Quantity has a quality all of its own. I think you're absolutely correct, and you point out a good reason why self-moderation can be insufficient upon reaching this "critical mass". My benefit is that ours is not a forum-based platform but mostly chat, so it's much more likely for at least one moderator to see each message or at least the most obviously wrong ones. Would you say that, as the quantity increases, effective moderation becomes key?