Murder is good, everyone!
By "murder" I mean the process of deciding that you don't like something and then acting to get rid of it. For example, if you have some old clothes that are starting to develop holes—don't just tolerate them and be miserable, be proactive and get rid of them! Murder your worn-out clothes! For another example that I'm sure would appeal to rationalists, if you used to believe something but now you have strong evidence it's wrong, don't cling to your old position—murder your false beliefs!
Of course, there are some distasteful things that people often think of when they hear "murder". But I favor a wider definition of the term, encompassing many valuable and beneficial practices; I'm not saying every murder is good, but the general idea is good and has applications everywhere in life. With a proper understanding of what it means, we should all set out to commit murder every day!
"Religion" means what it means—probably somewhat different things to different people. But I think most people would agree it implies "a set of beliefs matching certain criteria" (some would say those beliefs are the religion, others might say they're merely an essential part of an organizational or cultural structure that is the religion). For rarely-used words, you might have a hope of deliberately changing the definition, but that's not the case for "religion". And as long as "religion" means what it does, adopting the slogan "Religion is good" means promoting mainstream religions, the Catholic Church, and so on.
Theses you might have picked instead:
I think it would be more correct to say that a focus on believing particular assertions is a fairly recent trend in religion, encompassing the past millennium or two, but really picking up in the last few centuries.
It happened in or between Christianity and Islam (as isusr points out), and they probably both influenced each other. For example, Protestant Christianity focuses a lot more on a holy book than Catholicism and Orthodox Christianity, but in a way that resembles Islam's veneration of the Quran: citing verses to prove points. Since then, Catholics ... (read more)
This is a casually written post in a series about what I wish someone had told me when I was younger.
I know this one will be controversial, so I have a request: please only vote on this post if you actually read the whole thing. Don't just vote to yell "boo religion" or "yay Gordon" or something. That's not really helpful and goes against site norms.
Note to mods: this is maybe a good example of a post that would benefit from top-level agree/disagree voting in addition to karma votes.
I didn't grow up religious in any real sense. My parents were raised Protestant Christians. They certainly brought me up with much of the ethos of it, but we never went to church other than on very rare occasions. I have almost no memories of going to church. The only time I can remember going was for my youngest sister's baptism.
They did tell us Bible stories, but I basically thought of them the same way as Greek myths: stories about people in the past who did fantastical things. I had no idea that some people took these stories super seriously.
So it came as some surprise when, one day in 7th grade, one of my friends asked me during PE if I was a Christian. I was like "uh, what's a Christian?". He asked me some questions about Jesus and I was like "who? what?". Then he asked "do you celebrate Christmas?". "Yeah," I said. "Okay, then you're a Christian! You should come to our meeting after school!"
I quickly found out a few things:
Over the next few years Christians gave me a lot of trouble. Some of them objected to things like evolution and the big bang and were annoying distractions in science class. Some of them told me I was going to burn in hell for eternity. But mostly they forced an identity on me—atheist—and I had to figure out what that meant, why I should feel bad about it, and eventually how to defend myself to Christians.
I eventually grew to like being an atheist. It was fun to argue with Christians and poke holes in their beliefs. I got to be a cool outcast fighting the good fight for truth and rationality.
But eventually, maybe 7 or 8 years ago, I began to suspect that I was mistaken about something. The Christians still clearly believed a lot of strangely specific and wrong things, and they were still strangely obsessed with believing things because there was no evidence as a "test of faith". But I began to realize that maybe there was something useful about religion.
What is religion? There's a bunch of formal definitions. I'm going to say it's this: a religion is a cultural and social thing where people seriously dedicate themselves to something, demonstrate their dedication via acts and beliefs, and by doing so live a life they consider more worth living than if they didn't.
That's pretty broad and not a normal definition of religion. Why would I want to define it like this? So I can capture lots of things that have the shape of religion but don't have content everyone would agree is sacred.
Some things I'd consider religions but traditional definitions don't always include. Note that for some of these some people do these things as religions and others don't.
Why such an expansive definition? Because it's my belief that humans are naturally religious. Our minds are structured to be part of a culture with certain features and the way you get those features is by creating religions in approximately the sense I mean here. The things humans want out of religions:
Lots of people think they don't want these things, though, so what gives? My guess is that the people who say they don't want these things are mostly responding defensively to having been previously harmed by one or more religions. It might have even been a traditional big-R Religion like Christianity or Islam or Judaism or Hinduism or Buddhism or something else. So if someone tries to get them to do rituals or give them advice in a "religious" context they get weirded out and want to run away from it.
But I'm here to say that religion as a concept is good. Any particular religion or religious organization might be bad. This is no different than how food as a concept is good but particular foods might be bad for you.
Religion, as I see it, fills a critical psychological need for humans. Without sufficient religion, we're lost. We suffer a meaningness crisis, if you will. Lots of Western people suffer from this today, especially if they are well educated. They've thrown off traditional religion and are uncomfortable with getting too close to substitute religions, and if they do get close they're unwilling to acknowledge it as a religion (and, given how religion is normally defined, that's pretty reasonable).
But having meaning in your life is great. Having rituals to perform is comforting. Having fellowship means you're never lonely. Having a ready source of life advice means you can just live a better life by learning from the hard-won experience of others.
My own journey was to find a traditional religion that I clicked with. I spent about 2 years doing everything I could to find any other solution. In the end, I realized I could only get what I needed if I started to show up and worship/practice with other people in a shared tradition. Hence why I'm now an ordained lay practitioner of Soto Zen, even taking on the dharma name Seidoh as a sign of dedication (and my name translates as "sincere way", just in case you weren't clear how dedicated I am).
So, in the end, I'm not going to say you should run out and become a Christian or join whatever local religion is popular. Probably that would end badly in a bunch of ways and whatever reason you already have to not want to do that stands. But what I am going to claim is that you need one or more religions, as I've construed them, in your life, and your life is impoverished without them.