I’m on the side of AI Safety. AI has a good chance of ending the human species if we don’t do it right, and Not Doing It Right is the default outcome unless we’re very cautious.
PauseAI is an activist group that advocates for AI Safety. They adopt the language, aesthetics, and tactics of “activism.” The splash page of their website demands “DON’T LET AI COMPANIES GAMBLE WITH OUR FUTURE”. They encourage people to add a Pause symbol to their online handles. They can be seen protesting outside AI company HQs.
I agree with their goal. I’ve met some of them and they are good, thoughtful people. In most ways we are aligned. However I think they are harmful for the cause of AI Safety and they should drastically change everything they’re doing.
Increasingly activists are seen as defect-bots. Activists are frequently found to:
Destroy (or attempt to destroy) irreplaceable artistic works or cultural artifacts. Shut down public services and thoroughfares. Suppress scientific findings considered hostile to their message. Blatantly lie about the words and actions of their opponents. Mandate educational programs that denigrate and insult their participants. In extreme cases they’ll actually celebrate the destruction of significant parts of cities/neighborhoods, and celebrate summary execution carried out by lunatics.
Activists come with an aura of low-key evil. They cannot be trusted with things you value, because everything is thought of as a tool to further the cause.You cannot believe what they say, because they care far more about their cause than about truth.
PauseAI does not do this, to be clear. But PauseAI embraces the aesthetics of groups that do these things. Therefore they associate the cause of AI Safety with activism. This will soon repel more people than it draws, if it doesn’t do so already. Resources being spent on PauseAI make the public less trusting of AI Safety arguments and should be diverted to almost anything else.
Interestingly enough, this applies to corporate executives and bureaucracy leaders as well. Many see the world in a very zero-sum way (300 years ago and most of history before that, virtually all top intellectuals in virtually all civilizations saw the universe as a cycle where civilizational progress was a myth and everything was an endless cycle of power being won and lost by people born/raised to be unusually strategically competitive) but fail to realize that, in aggregate, their contempt for cause-having people ("oh, so you think you're better than me, huh? you think you're hot shit?") have turned into opposition to positive-sum folk, itself a cause of sorts, though with an aversion to activism and assembly and anything in that narrow brand of audacious display.
It doesn't help that most 'idealistic' causes throughout human history had a terrible epistemic backing.
3brambleboy
Yeah, I think the mainstream view of activism is something like "Activism is important, of course. See the Civil Rights and Suffrage movements. My favorite celebrity is an activist for saving the whales! I just don't like those mean crazy ones I see on the news."
That mainstream is like one side of the American political spectrum, now also do the other side. ;)
Seems to me there are three factors to how one perceives an activist, most important first:
Do I support their agenda, or do I oppose it?
If I oppose their agenda, how threatened do I feel by their activism? If I support their agenda, how devastating blow do I think they delivered to my enemies?
How do the activists actually behave? Do they politely express their opinions? Do they destroy public and private property? Do they attack other people?
I’m on the side of AI Safety. AI has a good chance of ending the human species if we don’t do it right, and Not Doing It Right is the default outcome unless we’re very cautious.
PauseAI is an activist group that advocates for AI Safety. They adopt the language, aesthetics, and tactics of “activism.” The splash page of their website demands “DON’T LET AI COMPANIES GAMBLE WITH OUR FUTURE”. They encourage people to add a Pause symbol to their online handles. They can be seen protesting outside AI company HQs.
I agree with their goal. I’ve met some of them and they are good, thoughtful people. In most ways we are aligned. However I think they are harmful for the cause of AI Safety and they should drastically change everything they’re doing.
Increasingly activists are seen as defect-bots. Activists are frequently found to:
Destroy (or attempt to destroy) irreplaceable artistic works or cultural artifacts.
Shut down public services and thoroughfares.
Suppress scientific findings considered hostile to their message.
Blatantly lie about the words and actions of their opponents.
Mandate educational programs that denigrate and insult their participants.
In extreme cases they’ll actually celebrate the destruction of significant parts of cities/neighborhoods, and celebrate summary execution carried out by lunatics.
Activists come with an aura of low-key evil. They cannot be trusted with things you value, because everything is thought of as a tool to further the cause. You cannot believe what they say, because they care far more about their cause than about truth.
PauseAI does not do this, to be clear. But PauseAI embraces the aesthetics of groups that do these things. Therefore they associate the cause of AI Safety with activism. This will soon repel more people than it draws, if it doesn’t do so already. Resources being spent on PauseAI make the public less trusting of AI Safety arguments and should be diverted to almost anything else.