376

LESSWRONG
LW

375
Privacy / Confidentiality / Secrecy
Personal Blog

12

Link: Snowden interviewed

by polymathwannabe
12th Nov 2014
1 min read
3

12

Privacy / Confidentiality / Secrecy
Personal Blog

12

Link: Snowden interviewed
0fortyeridania
1eof
1fortyeridania
New Comment
3 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 5:02 AM
[-]fortyeridania11y00

It would be helpful if you explained a little more. What makes this article relevant to the LW community?

Reply
[-]eof11y10

It seems self-evident to me that topics of mass surveillance, modern martyrs, and the exposing the lies of (for better or worse) the ruling class, would be of interest to those trying to act rationally.

But I am new here; and maybe there is more a burden of a specific thesis?

Reply
[-]fortyeridania11y10

topics of mass surveillance, modern martyrs, and the exposing the lies of (for better or worse) the ruling class, would be of interest to those trying to act rationally

I think they would be of interest. But the same holds in general for all true information. It's usually nice if the contributor provides a more specific reason.

The specific topics in this particular post deserve extra justification for two reasons. The first is that they are highly politicized. The second is that the link is to a decidedly political source. This can lead to poor-quality discussion.

It's good to discourage opinionated link-dumping. Whether this qualifies as opinionated link-dumping or not, a norm of providing a justification for such posts would discourage the practice. By asking for justification, I was contributing to such a norm.

Reply
Moderation Log
More from polymathwannabe
View more
Curated and popular this week
3Comments

"The atomic bomb was the moral moment for physicists. Mass surveillance is the same moment for computer scientists, when they realize that the things they produce can be used to harm a tremendous number of people."

http://www.alternet.org/world/snowden-i-did-what-i-did-because-i-believe-it-right-thing-do?paging=off