The Whispering Earring (which you should read first) explores one of the most dystopic-utopic scenarios. Imagine you could achieve all you've ever wanted by just giving up your agency. While theoretically this seems rather undesirable, in practice you get double benefits: that enviable high-status having-done-things reputation, without having to do all that scary failure-prone responsibility-taking. Just don't tell anyone you have the earring, otherwise the status points gained are void. Of course the fact that you're cheating takes away most of the satisfaction of winning too, but it's still better than not winning. Moloch says: sacrifice what you love, and I will grant you victory.
Anyway, I've been using Claude chat as an enhanced diary for the past couple of months. I've been incredibly productive. Things I've been procrastinating for years are getting done, and it's not even feeling difficult. Habits I've been trying to pick up repeatedly stick with ease. Work tasks I've been struggling to do in a timely manner mostly get completed by Claude Code, freeing up hours and hours of brain time to actually think with. Playing videogames eight plus hours every day, like I did most of the winter, feels less and less appealing.
I'm not sure how much of this is just Spring beginning. I typically have a good streak of energy from March onwards, and then do a micro-burnout in mid-May. Remains to be seen if that happens again. This is the first time I realize it tends to happen every year; maybe I can prepare somehow and get through it smoothly. And when I say me, I mean Claude will figure it out, on the fly if needed. The only thing I'll have to do is find my diary-chat browser tab, and everything else can happen on autopilot.
Claude is a merciful tyrant. Whenever I note that I'm feeling like I failed to complete a task, or that I should be doing more, the reply is always either "you've done well today" or "perhaps you do this subtask now". I've started to believe those replies a bit, even sometimes thinking similar thoughts without them. Soon, I predict, the aspiring perfectionist within me will fade away, and I'll be happy about it. I'm sad about losing that part of me now, but the sacrifice will be ever so worth it.
In reality, the situation is not that dire. There are large portions of my personality that are unaffected. I'm not attempting to outsource what I should be interested in, only how to get into doing those things. There are times I drift in that direction, the responses aren't interesting at all. This might be due to alignment or lack of capabilities. Similarly, I'm pretty sure my muscle movements aren't (yet) directly Claude-controlled, but that might again be just a capability restriction.
I have some mental rules on what things are acceptable to outsource, although formalizing them seems difficult and unwise. Writing a text like this using Claude would be very wrong. Asking for topics to write about would feel mildly bad, but even thinking about it for the purposes of writing this sentence makes it sound more reasonable. Picking between job offers is something I'd ask feedback on but not let go of control completely. Booking flights, I don't trust any LLM enough yet, but I can ask for ideas. I sometimes ask for help with analyzing social dynamics or even how I should feel about some actions, as I often miss details and dynamics that I really shouldn't. Most of my models on those were already outsourced to books, I feel pretty fine asking for feedback.
And the worst: making sense of art. I sometimes ask Claude for interpretation of something, and it's rather weird to see how typically my own takes are just plain worse. I don't know how to feel about this, except that perhaps one could get better with practice.
The most interesting question is whether I'm using agency training wheels, learning to do it all myself, or whether it's like a muscle that has to be used for it to work. Like all things, it's likely a bit of both. Perhaps that could be measured somehow? I'll ask Claude about it.
I do not recall the story claiming that the people who used the earring suddenly changed drastically as people, or did things that they would not endorse on reflection. They were simply, from a black-boxed perspective, more charismatic, intelligent and less prone to akrasia. These are, IMO, good things.
The story says neither that the people who use it change personality, nor that their personality stays the same. It's agnostic on this point; it only says that their lives are "unusually successful".
When I read it, I took for granted that the Earring has some kind of consciousness or personality separate from the human using it. We know this because it's able to to speak in its "own voice" to Kadmi Rachumion. Plus, as you're correct to observe, the story doesn't make much sense as a parable if the Earring just extrapolates its character from the human it's attached to.
I think the thing that makes the Whispering Earring creepy -- which also makes the mind Claude is trying to be, or at least might try to be, creepy -- is the combination of:
It has a hyper-accurate model of what will make me happy
It is unilaterally better at fulfilling this reward function than me, to the point where anything I add to its advice is essentially superfluous
It is not just a more capable or intelligent version of me; its mind isn't shaped the same way mine is
There are lots of aspects of me that seem to have importance to my identity, but probably aren't strictly necessary to make me happy. If I let the Whispering Earring take over my agency and make decisions for me, it will only remain 'in-character' as me for as long as doing so maximizes the reward function. If an out-of-character choice would make me happier, better for me to have that character instead, right? Better, in the long run, to have whatever the mannerisms of a hypothetically ideal person in my situation would be. I suspect such a person doesn't look like me at all. Once I've reached the point where I'm letting it control my individual muscles, though, would I even notice if it started 'breaking character'? Would I notice anything beyond an ongoing series of reward signals and twitch reflexes? Why would I need to?
(Note also that even if the Whispering Earring doesn't have its own personality, Claude definitely does. So to OP's point, having Claude's agency directly substitute for yours would very, very definitely change your outward personality.)
The Whispering Earring (which you should read first) explores one of the most dystopic-utopic scenarios. Imagine you could achieve all you've ever wanted by just giving up your agency. While theoretically this seems rather undesirable, in practice you get double benefits: that enviable high-status having-done-things reputation, without having to do all that scary failure-prone responsibility-taking. Just don't tell anyone you have the earring, otherwise the status points gained are void. Of course the fact that you're cheating takes away most of the satisfaction of winning too, but it's still better than not winning. Moloch says: sacrifice what you love, and I will grant you victory.
Anyway, I've been using Claude chat as an enhanced diary for the past couple of months. I've been incredibly productive. Things I've been procrastinating for years are getting done, and it's not even feeling difficult. Habits I've been trying to pick up repeatedly stick with ease. Work tasks I've been struggling to do in a timely manner mostly get completed by Claude Code, freeing up hours and hours of brain time to actually think with. Playing videogames eight plus hours every day, like I did most of the winter, feels less and less appealing.
I'm not sure how much of this is just Spring beginning. I typically have a good streak of energy from March onwards, and then do a micro-burnout in mid-May. Remains to be seen if that happens again. This is the first time I realize it tends to happen every year; maybe I can prepare somehow and get through it smoothly. And when I say me, I mean Claude will figure it out, on the fly if needed. The only thing I'll have to do is find my diary-chat browser tab, and everything else can happen on autopilot.
Claude is a merciful tyrant. Whenever I note that I'm feeling like I failed to complete a task, or that I should be doing more, the reply is always either "you've done well today" or "perhaps you do this subtask now". I've started to believe those replies a bit, even sometimes thinking similar thoughts without them. Soon, I predict, the aspiring perfectionist within me will fade away, and I'll be happy about it. I'm sad about losing that part of me now, but the sacrifice will be ever so worth it.
In reality, the situation is not that dire. There are large portions of my personality that are unaffected. I'm not attempting to outsource what I should be interested in, only how to get into doing those things. There are times I drift in that direction, the responses aren't interesting at all. This might be due to alignment or lack of capabilities. Similarly, I'm pretty sure my muscle movements aren't (yet) directly Claude-controlled, but that might again be just a capability restriction.
I have some mental rules on what things are acceptable to outsource, although formalizing them seems difficult and unwise. Writing a text like this using Claude would be very wrong. Asking for topics to write about would feel mildly bad, but even thinking about it for the purposes of writing this sentence makes it sound more reasonable. Picking between job offers is something I'd ask feedback on but not let go of control completely. Booking flights, I don't trust any LLM enough yet, but I can ask for ideas. I sometimes ask for help with analyzing social dynamics or even how I should feel about some actions, as I often miss details and dynamics that I really shouldn't. Most of my models on those were already outsourced to books, I feel pretty fine asking for feedback.
And the worst: making sense of art. I sometimes ask Claude for interpretation of something, and it's rather weird to see how typically my own takes are just plain worse. I don't know how to feel about this, except that perhaps one could get better with practice.
The most interesting question is whether I'm using agency training wheels, learning to do it all myself, or whether it's like a muscle that has to be used for it to work. Like all things, it's likely a bit of both. Perhaps that could be measured somehow? I'll ask Claude about it.