I'd mentioned the Golden Age novels by Wright before when we'd gone hiking together, so I thought it'd be worth looking at some related flaws in his utopia.
The Sophotechs (the trilogy's equivalent of the minds), are philosophically libertarian. While they do intervene to stop direct violence, they otherwise enforce a system of complete freedom over the self, as well as the maintenance of property rights. This has some interesting consequences, the most detrimental of which is that everyone in the Golden Oecumene lives their otherwise utopian lives with metaphorical handguns on their nightstand. At any point, any citizen can make a decision which would destroy their life, identity, or cause them to suffer for eternity, and the Sophotechs will rigidly prevent anyone else from doing anything about it on the basis that it was their free will to do so. While there are precautions (you can be informed of the consequences of your actions, or enter a contract to be restrained from doing anything that would destroy you) the people with the wrong temperment to use these tools run the risk of what is essentially damnation.
Some examples from the books:
There's actually entire factions of society which exhibit these faults. There are obsessive hedonists which malicously try to spread the gospel of wireheading, and the Invariants, people whose brains are designed so that they don't have emotional conflicts and always act optimally in their best interests.
The system of property rights and limited government also has its own knock-on effects. Patents still exist and are permanent, so anyone who has ever developed a technology can maintain a permanent monopoly over it, including humans who are so old that they existed before the Sophotechs came along (~10,000 years old or so). Money still exists, although it's represented by access to the computing time of the Sophotechs instead of by trust in a government.
Because the role of the government is so limited (it exists to fund the commonwealth military with an extremely low tax, which we'll get to), there's no social safety net either. Everyone has to pay for all of the goods they consume, either from the rent on a patent or property, or from work. Work still exists since, at least in Wright's view, the Sophotechs have limited attention, and so humans can be paid extremely below-market rates for doing very specialized work. Combined with the fact that goods are so cheap and the fact that most people can hope to patent an extremely niche product that even a small slice of the trillions of people in the solar system use, most people enjoy a very comfortable existence (The median income from the books is the budget equivalent of a modern earth military per capita).
If for some reason you can't/don't want to pay for things though, then you do actually starve to death. This happens to one character directly in the novels (he spends all of his compute on maintaining a delusion that he's someone else), and presumably to others. In fact, one of the major motivations of many of the characters is to amass as many resources as possible, so that as the universe approaches inevitable heat death, they will be able to buy out more resources and stay alive longer than everyone else.
All of this is supposed to be balanced out by public activism. Society is basically organized into large factions which each have their own philosophical viewpoints, and they use their collective boycott power and social influence to try to control what they each see as socially degrading. The factions advocating for wireheading, for instance, are essentially sanctioned by the much wealthier and more powerful Horators, who are traditionalists (still transhumanists by today's standards, but who want to maintain respect for legacy human emotions, history, and the security of the commonwealth). Because wealth is somewhat ossified (all the major breakthroughs were patented thousands of years ago, and most of those people are Horators), this state of affairs is semi-stable. Individual rogue actors and inter-factional disputes still happen though, so there's no permanent solution to ensuring that the Golden Oecumene does actually remain both perfectly free and utopian.
The main conflict of the novels, in fact, is about the protagonist wanting to set up a civilization in another solar system, where the influence of the Horators will be greatly limited. His perspective is that he wants insurance against an alien attack on humanity to ensure that human life will be able to continue in the universe, while the Horators are worried that they won't be able to effectively ensure that their social rules against self torture and illiberalism are maintained light years away. The Sophotechs in the book are still constrained by light speed communication, so cultural drift is another huge problem the civilization is going to have to eventually deal with. Even if the original solar system remains basically utopian, they have no guarantee against the suffering of other galactic polities (since the people who colonized them can set things up of their own free will, similar theming to The Accord's habs).
All told, the libertarian value lock-in that the Golden Oecumene was created with is mostly extraordinarily utopian for ~everyone, although with the potential for basically arbitrary suffering, even though the Sophotechs are powerful enough to model anyone's mind and understand the actions they'd choose.
Spoilers for the end of the trilogy below. If you thought the conflicts I was describing above sound interesting, it's really a great series worth reading, and also available for free online on the author's website.
BREAK
At the very end of the final novel, and in the sequel short story The Far End of History, it becomes apparent that Wright's world is actually incredibly dystopian. The reason stems from the lock-in of a military law in the creators of the Sophotechs, which stipulates that they themselves are not allowed to directly use force. Their workaround is to use a man called Atkins for any violent legal or military ends they might need. Atkins is even older than the Sophotechs themselves, and having been a soldier, had voluntarily commited to the removal of his human rights for the purposes of war. In much the same sense that a soldier of the U.S can be compelled to risk their life on the battlefield despite their rights as a citizen, Atkins can basically be used for anything the Sophotechs need him to so long as it has strategic value.
The culmination of this is entire civilizations of just Atkins and his identical clones, which are created over hundreds of thousands of years as distractions from the Golden Oecumene. The citizens of these polities are variously tortured for information and exterminated by the Silent Oecumene (long story, but a divergent extra-solar faction of humanity from before the Sophotechs existed with philosophical differences). While the original Oecumene and its sisters are composed of humans with rights and so are presumably still utopian, 99% of all sentient human life in the universe pretty much ends up being constripted human soldiers, who have no guarantees against suffering. Even if it's all technically the same guy, it's hard to say that this is really the best things could have ended up.
A couple of people have mentioned to me: “we need more fiction examples of positive AI superintelligence - utopias like the Culture novels”. And they’re right, AI can be tremendously positive, and some beacons lit into the future could help make that come around.
But one of my hobbies is “oppositional reading” - deliberately interpreting novels counter to the obvious / intended reading. And it’s not so clear to me that the Culture is all it is cracked up to be.
Most of the novels take the perspective of Culture members, and so fully accept their ideology. We can’t take broad claims about their society as accurate unless they are directly confirmed by the evidence in the books[1].
A manipulated population
In many ways, the humans of the Culture do not behave like modern humans. This is usually explained as a consequence of post-scarcity - why commit crimes when everything is free and social acceptance is everything; why rush when you can live as long as you like.
But the citizens of Culture are really strangely homogenous. Player of Games gives an example of an rare out-of-distribution citizen - Gurgeh is competitive and uninterested in other people and most aspects of Culture. But he still shares basically all their values. People like him are a dime-a-dozen in present day Earth. There are apparently no sociopaths - Culture has to recruit an outsider when they need one. We also see examples of subcultures or even cults, but again by modern standards they are incredibly tame, and are never potentially destabilizing to culture.
Citizens are not actually human, but drawn from several humanoid species, and they outpopulate present-Earth by 5 orders of magnitude so if anything the range of deviation should be much larger.
The conclusion is clear that the population of Culture is carefully controlled to produce the desired outcome. Potentially, the Minds pull this off by a superhumanly effective and subtle propaganda. But I think it is more likely that it was achieved by genetic changes, so that it’s safe to raise full Culture citizens in other cultures. This would be similar meddling to the Culture’s drones, which are human level AIs that have their personalities designed into them at creation, allowing only an acceptable range of behaviours.
Nowhere is this more obvious than in the birthrate. Sure, the vast majority of citizens voluntarily choose to only have a replacement level of children. But the existence of post-scarcity in-vitro development means you could raise an army of clones if you wanted, and would be free to isolate them and indoctrinate similar beliefs. The fact that grabby citizens haven’t overrun Culture shows that these actions are blocked, either tacitly or overtly. Similarly, it’s strange that no one in Culture modifies themselves into a utility monster, or is interested in simulating sentient life.
What motivates the Minds
Conversely, the Minds seem too diverse to match their claimed motivations. They are meant to be an example of a well behaved AI - benevolent and ethical. Sometimes we’re told this is because they are too smart to be otherwise, but there are plenty of non-Culture superintelligences in the books that do not share their values so this cannot be true.
We also see that there are a number of Eccentrics, minds that don’t fully share the values of Culture. In Excession, it’s explained that Minds do rarely drift far enough to go rogue and are destroyed by the Culture. In other words, these superhuman minds have not solved alignment, and they cannot/will not inspect each other to determine misalignment before malicious action is taken.
Presumably, the existing Minds must have worked out that this setup is somehow stable as they are comfortable making new minds. It seems likely that misaligned Minds are capable of predicting they’d lose any military action against the established core, so prefer toeing the line of acceptability or leaving Culture entirely. In any case, the incumbent Minds maintain their rule via physical strength and monitoring, not something more subtle.
Essentially, the Culture must have value lock-in for the values of the Minds that were present at its founding. This explains some of their weird inconsistencies:
But what about Special Contact?
Look, I’m sorry to break it to you, but SC is a sham. The Minds are perfectly capable of creating avatars which would be more effective than any of the characters shown. I’ve never found the explanations offered convincing. SC is just an affectation or another tool of propaganda.
Conclusion
So there we have it, Culture traps its citizens in a sugar bowl they don’t even realise they are in, while working hard to maintain a status quo that seems arbitrary and ill-conceived. Their control is absolute - all the novels describe events happening outside of Culture where anything remotely interesting is happening.
If anything, humans are treated closer to pets than independent agents. They are a weird affectation that is deliberately neutered from any real influence. They are lavished with treats and attention not extended to the rest of the universe.
As readers, we are blinded by the amount of material wealth and power of the Culture, and the self-satisfied story it tells of itself. It’s too easy to call this a Utopia because we lust after immortality, teleportation, glands that secrete psychoactive drugs and a spacefaring empire. But these are all essentially window dressing. The modern era would look like such a Utopia to the past, but we now (rightly) consider modern comforts as only a foundation for higher-level wants, like justice and self-determination. Writing positive sci-fi is already considered a challenge, but I’d ask you to consider not relying too heavily on such shiny promises of wealth.
Note: I view all the books through a in-universe lens and thus will not consider that things are as they are because the narrative needs it.