Empiric status: My own idea written up with the help of Gemini 2.0 Experimental in dialog.

We're still coasting on the fumes of 1940s data when it comes to water fluoridation. Back then, fluoride toothpaste was a novelty, fluoridated salt was uncommon, and water filters were practically science fiction, let alone ones that can selectively remineralize with or without fluoride.

We're navigating a multi-variable optimization problem blindfolded. We have fluoride inputs from water, toothpaste, and salt, all interacting in poorly understood ways, impacting both cavity rates and, more concerningly, cognitive development.

The IQ Elephant Continues to Loom Large

The potential neurotoxic effects of fluoride are no longer a fringe concern. National Toxicology Program (NTP) monograph is clear: "moderate confidence" that >1.5 mg/L fluoride in drinking water associates with lower IQ in children.

The technology is here. We can do this right. Modern water filters with remineralization cartridges are the key.

Here's the plan:

Factorial Design: Multiple arms to test different combinations of:
- Water Fluoride Levels:
  - 0 mg/L (placebo - remineralization without fluoride)
  - 0.35 mg/L (half of the current CDC recommendation, exploring potential lower thresholds)
  - 0.7 mg/L (current CDC recommendation)
- Toothpaste:
  - Standard fluoridated toothpaste (provisioned, with standardized use instructions)
  - Non-fluoridated toothpaste (provisioned, with standardized use instructions)
- Salt:
  - Fluoridated salt (provisioned)
  - Non-fluoridated salt (provisioned)
  This creates a 3x2x2 factorial design, allowing us to disentangle the effects of each source and their interactions, with a clear focus on the impact of fluoridated salt.
Targeted Community Selection: Conduct the study in a community with known poor water quality. This offers multiple benefits:
- Ethical Appeal: Providing free, high-quality water filters is a significant social good.
- High Participation Rates: The offer of free water filtration will be very well-received.
- Enhanced Compliance: Participants receiving a tangible benefit (clean water) are more likely to adhere to the study protocol, including consistent filter cartridge replacement.
Randomized, double-blind (as much as possible) allocation of households within the selected community to each of the experimental arms.
Longitudinal data collection: Track dental health (cavities, etc.) and, crucially, cogni

...

Medical Paradigms

Medical Paradigms