The Darwinian Trap
Global coordination stands as arguably the most critical challenge facing humanity today, functioning both as a necessary component for solving existential risks and as a significant barrier to effective mitigation. From nuclear proliferation to artificial intelligence development and climate change, our inability to collaborate effectively on a global scale not only exacerbates these threats but also perpetuates the emergence of new systemic vulnerabilities if left unaddressed.
In this sequence, I will argue that the root of this coordination problem lies in the very mechanisms that shaped our species: natural selection. This evolutionary process, operating as a trial-and-error optimization algorithm, prioritizes immediate survival and reproduction over long-term, global outcomes. As a result, our innate tendencies often favor short-term gains and localized benefits, even when they conflict with the greater good of our species and planet.
The inherent limitations of natural selection in predicting future optimal states have left us ill-equipped to handle global-scale challenges. In a world of finite resources, competition rather than cooperation has often been the more adaptive trait, leading to the emergence of self-interested behaviors that arguably dominate modern societies. This evolutionary legacy manifests in the form of nationalistic tendencies, economic rivalries, dangerous arms races and a general reluctance to sacrifice immediate benefits for long-term collective gains.
This three-part series summarizes my book: The Darwinian Trap: The Hidden Evolutionary Forces That Explain Our World (and Threaten Our Future).
- Part 1: This part explores how evolutionary selection pressures contribute to existential risks, particularly through global resource, power, and intelligence arms races.
- Part 2: This part delves into the evolution of cooperation and discusses how survivorship bias might mislead us into thinking cooperation is easier to achieve than it actually is. It suggests that life may be inherently fragile, potentially containing the seeds of its own destruction, which could provide an explanation for the Fermi Paradox.
- Part 3: The final part examines strategies to overcome global coordination challenges, both through centralized and decentralized approaches. It introduces the concept of "reputational markets" (a variant of prediction markets) as a tool for supply chain governance, aimed at reshaping the evolutionary trajectory toward cooperation and long-term survival and flourishing.