Epistemic Status: Probably not necessary, certainly not sufficient.
Think you have a good AI alignment plan? Prove it!
Build some lower stakes mass influence system, like a social media platform, which implements your plan. If it is more engaging and more pro-social, then your plan will be worth looking at. No powerful AI should be deployed until the alignment plan can pass this basic test.
Alignment plans need to deal with the fundamental divide between machines doing what we tell them to do and machines doing what we want them to do. Any proposal that can address this problem can not be limited to a particular machine architecture. Thus, it should be able to be... (read more)