In terms of individual rationality, I hope I would notice my own severe confusion and then assign >50% probability to the majority vote.
I’m not sure how to formalize this, but it seems my level of conviction I have in the belief should also be a factor in this judgement of irrational or not.
In the experiment, the subject was equally capable as compared to the decoys at visual reasoning. However, that skill is only responsible for judging one situation - an honest experiment with no tricks. With something as obviously true as X being closest to C, that l... (read more)
I’m not sure how to formalize this, but it seems my level of conviction I have in the belief should also be a factor in this judgement of irrational or not.
In the experiment, the subject was equally capable as compared to the decoys at visual reasoning. However, that skill is only responsible for judging one situation - an honest experiment with no tricks. With something as obviously true as X being closest to C, that l... (read more)