User Profile

star50
description22
message3155

Recent Posts

Curated Posts
starCurated - Recent, high quality posts selected by the LessWrong moderation team.
rss_feed Create an RSS Feed
Frontpage Posts
Posts meeting our frontpage guidelines: • interesting, insightful, useful • aim to explain, not to persuade • avoid meta discussion • relevant to people whether or not they are involved with the LessWrong community.
(includes curated content and frontpage posts)
rss_feed Create an RSS Feed
All Posts
personIncludes personal and meta blogposts (as well as curated and frontpage).
rss_feed Create an RSS Feed

80% of data in Chinese clinical trials have been fabricated

2y
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
18

[LINK] Updating Drake's Equation with values from modern astronomy

2y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
3

Meetup : Tel Aviv Meetup: solving anthropic puzzles using UDT

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Meetup : Tel Aviv Meetup: Social & Board Games

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

When does heritable low fitness need to be explained?

3y
2 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
147

Meetup : Tel Aviv Meetup: Social & Board Games

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Meetup : Less Wrong Israel Meetup: Social and Board Games

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Meetup : Less Wrong Israel Meetup: Social and Board Games

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Meetup : Tel Aviv: Slightly Less Hard Problems of Consciousness

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Meetup : Less Wrong Israel Meetup: social and board games

3y
1 min read
Show Highlightsubdirectory_arrow_left
0

Recent Comments

Loyalty, authority, and fairness are also about other people. A lone person can't be loyal, authoritative, or fair; you have to be those things to someone else.

And, as I've been saying, Harm/Care is also about the conduct of the individual: do you harm others or care for them?

> "I can't learn the material for you" as opposed to "if you want to climb Mt Everest, you have to do it for yourself rather than for someone else".

I'm not sure I understand the difference, can you make it more explicit?

"I can't learn the material for you": if I learn it, it won't achieve the go...(read more)

I did not mean to misrepresent what lawyers do (or are allowed to do). I noted they are restricted by lawyer ethics, but that was in a different comment than the one you replied to. Yes, absolutely, they not supposed to lie or even deliberately mislead, and a lawyer's reputation would suffer horribl...(read more)

> Harm/Care is unusual among the foundations in that it's other-directed. The goal is to help other people, and it does not especially matter how that occurs. \[...\] In contrast, the other foundations centre on the moral actor themselves. I cannot be just, loyal, a good follower, or pure for you.

...(read more)

I think my definition of rhetoric is the same as OP's: namely, the art of shaping words or a speech to be beautiful, moving, convincing, or otherwise effective. How to best verbally convince others of an idea: I think that's a useful term.

In particular the OP referred to _dispositio_ (concise, add...(read more)

> I don’t think that’s true. Lots of people are bothered by this. Maybe you’re right, maybe a _majority_ is unbothered, but this is interesting only to the extent that it doesn’t embody a larger pattern of what proportion of people care about injustice.

I agree that most people are bothered by anyt...(read more)

> Are you sure? I’ve met a lot of people (“average people”, not rationalists) who take the view of “yeah, he can talk real impressively, but it’s all bullshit, no doubt”. Many people like “simple talk”, i.e. speech that simply lays out facts, and are suspicious of impressive/skillful rhetoric.

I've...(read more)

This seems to depend a lot on social context.

Lawyers are the quintessential speakers-for-hire who apply rhetoric to mercenary causes. Yet lawyers are accepted and high-status in most parts of society. In play, debate clubs are often popular; and at a recent LW meetup we played an Ideological Turin...(read more)

Unlike the regular trolley problem, this one is similar to moral choices made by many people every day. As you walk down the street, you see a man point a gun at another. Do you interpose your body to save the stranger's life at the cost of your own? Down another street, a man points a gun at you. T...(read more)

I agree, and I didn't mean to imply otherwise.