I actually have a new puppy - and it certainly has taken a little while for him to figure out that kibble is food so this part stood out to me :)
For example, dogs don’t learn to salivate whenever they see food. This reflex is ‘hard-wired’ into the dog
This doesn't require that dog have a hardwired food classifier. The behaviour is the dog salivating when the dog sees something it recognizes as food, not that the dog is able to recognize all foods. It just needs one hardwired FOOD neuron, that can be attached to a classifier that is later trained. (Idk the technical terms sorry!)
It might still be bullshit - but you'd have to do some experiment that determined whether dogs knew immediately to salivate in the presence of things they know to be food, or if dogs have to learn to salivate in the presence of things they know to be food, which Zitovich's experiment doesn't address because he gave the dog stuff it didn't realize was food.
Unless I'm just missing context, and Pavlov really did think the dog could recognize all types of food that exist from birth...
PS Also congratulations on finishing your PhD. I started one but didn't finish, so much respect from me.
All my notes take the form of questions and answers now. I find that notes that can't be used to challenge me to recall and think about the material are pointless.
Note these are not like SR flashcards, which I have had little luck with outside things such as vocab.
I keep them in markdown in Dropbox, and edit them on my iPad or phone while reading. When I feel like reviewing I have a custom style sheet to present them in a form that it is easy to cover up the answers with one hand.
In terms of deciding what information to capture, I used to fetishise names and dates and things. Nowadays I focus mainly on concepts (if the author names the concept it's gold) and the outlines of arguments, and try to keep the volume to only the most important info, since everything I put in there I expect to remember.
Sign up for Songkick.com and track the artists you named and the SF Bay Area metro area. I work at this company and we exist to solve this problem for live music. We only email you about stuff you have previously told us you are interested in.
After reading this story I spent about 30 seconds worrying that my ipad was broken because the display was now tinted pink. Even a restart didn't fix it. Then I realized.
Thank you, I'm not sure if I had seen that.
What techniques have you used for removing or beating Ugh Fields, with associated +/- figures?
(A search of LW reveals very few suggestions for how to do this.)
Awesome. I'm going to try this on something (short).
Random thoughts:
In the context of LW, I took it as an amusing critique of the whole idea of rewarding yourself for behaviours you want to do more .
"In particular, when it comes to marriage, outside of the aforementioned libertarian fringe, there is a total and unanimous agreement that marriage is not a contract whose terms can be set freely, but rather an institution that is entered voluntarily, but whose terms are dictated (and can be changed at any subsequent time) by the state."
If true, this is a new thing. In the past the terms were dictated by the church. I doubt you will find unanimous agreement today that the views of the church are irrelevant to marriage. So perhaps the total and unanimous agreement is something not quite so total, that can change more than this implies.
"Therefore, when I hear a libertarian argument applied to marriage, I conclude that there are only two possibilities:"
This seems to be a failure of imagination. How about number 3: they are an honest libertarian who thinks that a marriage contract should be a contract like any other, AND that there are certain rights that are not alienable through contract.
I think about my young daughters' lives a lot. One says she wants to be an artist. Another a teacher.
Do those careers make any sense on a timeframe of the next 20 years?
What interests and careers do I encourage in them that will become useless at the slowest rate?
I think about this a lot - and then I mainly do nothing about it, and just encourage them to pursue whatever they like anyway.