LESSWRONG
LW

David Hornbein
1323Ω-632870
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
Explaining British Naval Dominance During the Age of Sail
David Hornbein2mo200

A good summary, but it's worth noting that while the death penalty for failing to fight was on the books, Byng's execution was the only time it was ever actually carried out. It's a bit similar to how the US military legally has the authority to execute deserters, but in the past century has only ever exercised this once out of tens of thousand of sentences (Eddie Slovak during WWII).

From reading the autobiography of Lord Cochrane, an insanely aggressive and insanely successful captain during the Napoleonic Wars, my impression is that the Royal Navy was very concerned with the allocation of credit, glory, and prestige, as well as money prizes. He describes a system where officers are writing to the Admiralty headquarters to describe the meritorious or shameful actions of their peers and subordinates after every major action, and sometimes convoked courts martial to resolve disputes, as in the case of Lord Cochrane's rival Lord Gambier. Lord Cochrane also argues that the prize system is critical to maintaining the Royal Navy's morale and effectiveness.

Reply
Eukryt Wrts Blg
David Hornbein2mo1313

Overtly, OP is trying to shun Cremieux for failing to meet an assumed-widely-agreed "standard of care and compassion". This is obviously based on OP's belief that Cremieux's conduct is unacceptably outside the Overton window, even if they used the word "standard" instead of the word "Overton window". The only point of deploying phrases like "Hoo boy" and "do better" is to appeal to a social consensus. OP isn't being sneaky here or anything, you're just misinterpreting their dialect.

Reply
Cole Wyeth's Shortform
David Hornbein5mo1715

Selection bias isn't the whole story. The median paper in almost every field is notably worse than it was in, say, 1985. Academia is less selective than it used to be—in the U.S., there are more PhDs per capita, and the average IQ/test scores/whatever metric has dropped for every level of educational attainment.

Grab a journal that's been around for a long time, read a few old papers and a few new papers at random, and you'll notice the difference.

Reply
Eli's shortform feed
David Hornbein8mo30

OKcupid is certainly a better product for hundreds of thousands, or possibly millions, of unusually literate people, including ~all potential developers and most people in their social circles. It's not a small niche.

Reply
My motivation and theory of change for working in AI healthtech
David Hornbein9moΩ13244

What does your company do, specifically? I found the brief description at HealthcareAgents.com vague and unclear. Can you walk me through an example case of what you do for a patient, or something?

Reply
MichaelDickens's Shortform
David Hornbein9mo71

Hm, this timing suggests the change could be a consequence of Karnofsky stepping away from the organization.

Which makes sense, now that I think about it. He's by far the most politically strategic leader Open Philanthropy has had, so with him gone, it's not shocking they might revert towards standard risk-averse optionality-maxxing foundation behavior.

Reply
MichaelDickens's Shortform
David Hornbein9mo3342

"Open Phil higher-ups being friends with Anthropic higher-ups" is an understatement. An Open Philanthropy cofounder (Holden Karnofsky) is married to an Anthropic cofounder (Daniela Amodei). It's a big deal!

Reply
Eli's shortform feed
[+]David Hornbein10mo-137
Richard_Kennaway's Shortform
David Hornbein1y44

>Are the near-term prospects of AGI making long-term prospects like suspension less attractive?

No. Everyone I know who was signed up for cryonics in 2014 is still signed up now. You're hearing about it less because Yudkowsky is now doing other things with his time instead of promoting cryonics, and those discussions around here were a direct result of his efforts to constantly explain and remind people.

Reply
mesaoptimizer's Shortform
David Hornbein1y20

I agree with your argument here, especially your penultimate paragraph, but I'll nitpick that framing your disagreements with Groves as him being "less of a value add" seems wrong. The value that Groves added was building the bomb, not setting diplomatic policy.

Reply
Load More
26Smallpox vaccines are widely available, for now
2y
5
93The Unilateralist’s “Curse” Is Mostly Good
5y
16