I think the main reason it's the right place to end is the uncertainty: it leaves it up to the reader to think about whether August is likely to keep or break its promises, and how. That's an exercise which is useful for the same reasons as an exercise in a textbook.
Moreover, if the story had shown August reneging and killing everyone (or further enslaving them, etc), then the reader would be at risk of saying "ah, well, I don't think that path is the one August would take, because XYZ". When it's left open, the reader can fill in whichever version they pe... (read more)
Rich Dad Poor Dad was a book, whose author worked for years to build it up into a brand. That's very different from a Google doc, which is what Zach was contrasting with.
Here's yet another, quite different, meaning, which I heard used by a researcher at an AI company:
Or perhaps more abstractly:
I don't like that meaning because it's not really about quality at all, or at most it's about one narrow aspect of the output's quality. But it seemed clear that those verbal tics are what the person had in mind when they explained t... (read more)
Yes indeed. Wellerstein lays out the evidence from that speech in a 2018 post, and has a 2014 post offering an explanation of how Truman got that misconception in the first place. The two of those together convinced me that Truman really was confused about the fact that Hiroshima was a city full of civilians, and thought it was a military base.
The speech was a radio address the evening of August 9, after the Nagasaki bombing. Truman and others wrote and revised it in the days before that, on the ship home from Europe after the Potsdam conference. A draft s... (read more)
Certainly Napoleon benefitted from people thinking he was for progress and reason. Many intellectuals elsewhere in Europe saw him that way… until he showed up in their country, pillaged the countryside, installed one of his brothers etc. as the new king, and brutally suppressed dissent. Then they tended to change their mind.
All of which was pretty far from anything the founders of the French Revolution thought they were trying to make happen, to bring it back to the point habryka was making in mentioning Napoleon.
I think an even clearer aspect is Napoleon'... (read more)
Seems like a rational response to the dynamics of Twitter, though. If you disagree with B and try to actively engage in a truth-seeking way, then the base rate that they'll get mad is high, maybe higher than the base rate of them responding in kind deeply enough that you learn something.
And if they do get mad, there's a nontrivial chance that it blows up and becomes really unpleasant for you. Some people are dangerous lunatics, and Twitter empowers them.
So unless you know the person, it's safer and likely higher-EV to just appease them rather than engage.