Halfwitz

Halfwitz's Posts

Sorted by New

Halfwitz's Comments

Online Fun LW/SSC Meetup

I would be interested in organizing this if no one else will. Would like the tips

Interview on IQ, genes, and genetic engineering with expert (Hsu)

Not really. May be worth listening to while washing dishes or something but nothing essential.

Selecting Leaders with Random Sampling and Standardized Testing

If people agree the test is fair and the randomization is fair, I'm not convinced it would not be stable after a generation or two. Pure sortition does retain that advantage, the IQ filter reduces this but the filter could be adjusted to increase stability. For example, say it took only the 50th percentile. At this level, coordination would be difficult as no one would want to publicly admit they weren't eligible for sortition. Perhaps this would remain true if only the 90th percentile were selected, if not the 99th.

Open thread, Dec. 26, 2016 - Jan. 1, 2017

If anyone is interested in playing an AI box experiment game, I'd be interested in being the gatekeeper.

Reframing Average Utilitarianism

1)

Just be sure I'm understanding you correctly, what you're saying is average utilitarianism prescribes creating lives that are not worth living so long as they are less horrible than average. This does seem weird. Creating a life that is not worth living should be proscribed by any sane rule!

2)

I don't find this objection super compelling. Isn't the reason average utilitarianism was proposed was because people find mere addition unattractive?

3)

Another fine point. People with lives worth living shouldn't feel the need to suicide when they learn they are dragging down the average. I believe average preference utilitarianism is a patch for this though.

I can think of various patches, but I should probably read more on the topic first. Do you have any recommendations for a textbook or a book on population ethics?

[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply
MIRI's 2015 Winter Fundraiser!

200, or 400 if you count matching.

August 2015 Media Thread

I watched it based on this recommendation. I'll second it - great fun, great animation, but I don't mind CGI. I thought I detected some Hannu Rajaniemi influences, too.

Gubhtu V guvax vg fubhyq unir raqrq jvgu gur gjb wbvavat gur iblntr. Qvatb'f bowrpgvbaf gb fvzhyngvba jrer cheryl n znggre bs gur cbyvgvpf naq Natryn pyrneyl cersreerq yvsr nf na rz. Gur erny jbeyq ybbxrq cerggl pehzzl.

Stupid Questions August 2015

I imagine a lot of the selection was indirect selection for neoteny. I think it would be much, much harder to select for domestication in octopi, as they do not raise their young.

August 2015 Media Thread

I've been looking for a good Anime/Manga podcast? The one's I've found have been ok but not exactly what I'm hoping for. Anyone know of one?

Load More