LESSWRONG
LW

Lalartu2
1040
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
You are Underestimating The Likelihood That Convergent Instrumental Subgoals Lead to Aligned AGI
Lalartu23y30

For this outcome, everything below has to be true:

  1. Molecular nanotechnology is impossible.
  2. Maintaining infrastructure using only robots is impossible / highly impractical.
  3. It is not possible to genetically engineer a creature that is a vastly better maintenance worker than human.

Given that, 95% claim is very overconfident.

Reply
The Track Record of Futurists Seems ... Fine
Lalartu23y0-3

I disagree that "France in the Year 2000" predictions were wrong. If judged by function rather than aesthetics they are more than half accurate.

Reply
Fermi Paradox: Iron Age Milky Way
Lalartu23y10

First, there were industrial nations which were autocracies and lacked significant middle class. For example, Russian Empire of early 19 century. So the argument "no industry without middle class" is simply wrong.

Second, this chain of logic relies on every alien species having such social group as nobility. This is utterly absurd. For heritable social status, it is necessary that upper classes have the same (or lower) number of (surviving) children as commoners, otherwise in a few generations everybody would be a nobleman. This only happened because humans are poorly adapted to civilized life. For civilizations that exist for millions of years, evolution would definitely fix this.

Reply
How can I reconcile the two most likely requirements for humanities near-term survival.
Answer by Lalartu2Aug 30, 2022*10

We technologically plateau because we reach technological limits. There aren't many important technologies not invented yet, things like nanorobots, compact fusion reactors or Dyson spheres are impossible. Whether AI is developed or not is irrelevant. After a century or two of stagnation, civilization runs out of resources and declines to pre-industrial level. This is our future.

Reply
No posts to display.