"You're next to a body of water with plenty of adults nearby. There are many drowning children in the water, but it's still much less than the number of people who can immediately save them. Collectively, if a fraction of the people went in the water, there would be no...
Two weeks ago I wrote an introduction to normative decision theory, yet I haven’t made clear what decision algorithm should be used. Before that, I’d like to give some preliminaries. Generally speaking, Newcomb's Problem and the Smoking Lesion Problem represent counterexamples to CDT and EDT and show where they differ....
I. Introduction Let's define decision theory as the study of decisions, specifically their effects on outcomes. There are three main branches of decision theory: descriptive decision theory (how real agents make decisions), prescriptive decision theory (how real agents should make decisions), and normative decision theory (how ideal agents should make...
1. Definitions Let’s start by defining some terms. First, we ought to distinguish between what is positive and what is normative. A positive claim states what is, whereas a normative one states what ought to be. Through Hume’s famous guillotine, we cannot derive one from the other. Then it follows,...