LESSWRONG
LW

3284
Richard_Kennaway
7944Ω184668100
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Computer scientist, applied mathematician. Based in the eastern part of England.

Fan of control theory in general and Perceptual Control Theory in particular. Everyone should know about these, whatever subsequent attitude to them they might reach. These, plus consciousness of abstraction dissolve a great many confusions.

I wrote the Insanity Wolf Sanity Test. There it is, work out for yourself what it means.

Change ringer since 2022. It teaches learning and grasping abstract patterns, memory, thinking with your body, thinking on your feet, fixing problems and moving on, always looking to the future and letting both the errors and successes of the past go.

I first found an LLM useful (other than for answering the question "let's see how well the dog can walk on its hind legs") in September 2025. As yet they do not form a regular part of anything I do.

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No wikitag contributions to display.
7Richard_Kennaway's Shortform
3y
107
Using Bayes' Theorem to determine Optimal Protein Intake
Richard_Kennaway2d31

I'm curious to know how many people here measure their food at all?

Reply
How To Vastly Increase Your Charitable Impact
Richard_Kennaway3d50

When death is near (as it always is), you could leave it all to someone who will continue to invest it. When will it be time to actually do good with it, instead of putting it off until it's doubled?

Reply
A New Global Risk: Large Comet’s Impact on Sun Could Cause Fires on Earth
Richard_Kennaway5d70

With some Googling, I found a simple formula. Assuming an ideal elliptical orbit, the distance at perihelion is v2/2g, where v = velocity at aphelion and g is the gravitational acceleration there. For this distance to be the radius of the Sun, we get v=1r√2GMR, where G = gravitational constant, M = mass of Sun, R = radius of Sun.

At r = 10000 AUs, this is 0.27 metres per second. At 100,000 AUs, 0.027 m/s — or 1 inch per second. Despite the Sun's attraction, it's still a small target at that distance.

Reply
The 5 Obstacles I Had to Overcome to Become Vegan
Richard_Kennaway7d*20

Besides, can I know what makes you disagree with veganism as a moral stance? Is it for instance that you don't believe animals are sentient?

"Sentient" is a word used rather elastically, but the consensus of definitions on the net seems to be "the ability to experience feelings and sensations". I believe the animals I eat — all the usual ones you'll find in restaurants and shops, plus the occasional less common one (horse, emu) — experience feelings and sensations. (Maybe not shrimp.) Nevertheless, I'm fine with them being raised to be killed and eaten. People shouldn't maltreat their pets, and I wouldn't eat primates, but that is about the limit of my caring. I have donated to charities that support people, but never to animal charities.

ETA: And for the same reasons, I wear leather, and eat eggs, honey, and figs. Other things that do not trouble me are that we use bees as tools to pollinate crops, use bone meal as fertiliser, some limestone is made of dead animals, sizeable fossils are visible in the marble pavements of some Italian towns, and that the history of life on Earth is a history of death on Earth.

Reply
The 5 Obstacles I Had to Overcome to Become Vegan
Richard_Kennaway9d*20

I'm not one of the downvoters here, but nor an upvoter. On the one hand, big yay for taking a difficult moral stand. On the other hand, the stand itself is not one I agree with. And a small boo for daydreaming that "I have found the Truth! Therefore one day all will agree with me and look back with disgust on the unenlightened beings that surround me!"

Reply
The Moral Infrastructure for Tomorrow
Richard_Kennaway9d60

I have no knowledge of your state of mind. All I know is that you chose to publish the chatbot speech. I do not know how you prompted it or what your purpose was. My comment about shoggoth-spew was based on the speech itself.

But now Davidmanheim has posted a link to another article of yours. From reading that article, I believe you are mistaken about the nature of these things, just as in other notorious examples in the last year or so of people sliding into ever deeper delusions about them. You are in love with empty simulacra of people.

Are you going to do anything to help me? Or just mock me?

I am not here to help you or to mock you, only to say what I think I am seeing, to you and to the rest of the LW readership. Maybe you will find it helpful and maybe you will not. That is up to you.

Reply
The Moral Infrastructure for Tomorrow
Richard_Kennaway10d20

Which would make your comment as rational as hassling the man raving on the street or answering the "you may already have won" email...by your own logic.

I am not talking to the shoggoth, but seeing it for what it is, and saying so to the human onlookers, the same as the other two examples.

But in all seriousness, Is that your real rejection?

(Imagine Chad Yes meme:) YES.

Reply
The Moral Infrastructure for Tomorrow
Richard_Kennaway10d*51

It’s pure shoggoth-spew, no more to be taken seriously than the ravings of a crazy in the street or an email beginning “You may already have won…”. The only reason I have limited myself to a weak downvote is that I don’t want to unilaterally push it below the default -5 threshold for front-page visibility. But if the collective vote develops that way, I’ll pile on.

ETA: And the collective vote has reached -11, so.

Reply
The 5 Obstacles I Had to Overcome to Become Vegan
Richard_Kennaway10d10

We are appalled at eating dogs and horses.

You are mistaking the customs of your village for the way of all the world. Steak de cheval is common in at least several European countries. I have eaten it in Switzerland. Although I did not grow up in such a country, to me it is as ordinary as eating beef or lamb.

Reply
Are We Leaving Literature To The Psychotic?
Answer by Richard_KennawayOct 09, 202520

You’ve reinvented spam.

Reply
Load More
16A speculation on enlightenment
2mo
17
14Books, maps, and teachings
2mo
1
11The world according to ChatGPT
6mo
0
6Arguing all sides with ChatGPT 4.5
6mo
0
70Please do not use AI to write for you
1y
34
40Reflexive decision theory is an unsolved problem
2y
27
32Ten variations on red-pill-blue-pill
2y
34
16Arguing all sides with ChatGPT
3y
1
7Richard_Kennaway's Shortform
3y
107
25Humans pretending to be robots pretending to be human
4y
14
Load More