LESSWRONG
LW

1781
Tomás Orozco
0010
Message
Dialogue
Subscribe

Posts

Sorted by New

Wikitag Contributions

Comments

Sorted by
Newest
No posts to display.
No wikitag contributions to display.
Definitions of Causal Abstraction: Reviewing Beckers & Halpern
Tomás Orozco6y10

Dear John Wentworth:

I have a doubt regarding the implications of Beckers' paper on abstractions. I am a lawyer by profession so I'm venturing pretty far afield here, and I hope my question will not be too trivial.

Given that every constructive abstraction is also a τ - abstraction, there must be some surjective function τU that is compatible with τ . Hence, for constructive abstractions, must there also be mappings τ1U,…,τnU such that, τU(→uL)=τ1U(→z1U)⋅…⋅τnU(→znU) , where →ziU is the projection of →uL onto the variables in →ZiU ? In other words, must there also be a partition of the low-level exogenous variables where each partition is mapped to a distinct high-level variable? I missed τU in the definition of constructive abstraction..

Thank you!

[This comment is no longer endorsed by its author]Reply