LESSWRONG
LW

Wikitags
Main
3
IntroIntuitive
6
IntroAlgebraic
1
IntroTechnical
1
ExampleReal numbers
1

Real numbers are uncountable

Edited by Jason Gross, Eric B last updated 21st Oct 2016
Requires: ,

We present a variant of Cantor's diagonalization argument to prove the are . This that there exist [1].

We use the decimal representation of the real numbers. An overline ( ¯9 ) is used to mean that the digit(s) under it are repeated forever. Note that a.bcd⋯z¯¯¯9=a.bcd⋯(z+1)¯¯¯0 (if z<9; otherwise, we need to continue carrying the one); ∑∞i=k10−k⋅9=1⋅10−k+1+∑∞i=k10−k⋅0. Furthermore, these are the only equivalences between decimal representations; there are no other real numbers with multiple representations, and these real numbers have only these two decimal representations.

Theorem The real numbers are uncountable.

Proof Suppose, for , that the real numbers are ; suppose that f:Z+↠R is a surjection. Let rn denote the nth decimal digit of r, so that the fractional part of r is r1r2r3r4r5… Then define a real number r′ with 0≤r′<1 so that r′n is 5 if (f(n))n≠5, and 6 if (f(n))n=5. Then there can be no n such that r′=f(n) since r′n≠(f(n))n. Thus f is not surjective, contradicting our assumption, and R is uncountable. □

Note that choosing 5 and 6 as our allowable digits for r′ side-steps the issue that 0.¯¯¯9=1.¯¯¯0. %%

  1. ^︎

    Since the real numbers are an example of one.

Parents:
1
1
Uncountability
uncountable
Uncountability
constructively proves
contradiction
uncountable sets
Real number
real numbers
Real number
countable
Discussion9
Discussion9