Not sure if this is useful or not but an anecdote from a nonkidhaver:
I was playing The Binding of Isaac with my nephew, who was born more recently than it was published, and his guy died, but I was still going. I was just thinking about the game and I didn't notice right away, but at some point I realized that he was excitedly looking at the screen, hoping that I would win it for us, and experienced a step increase in how much I cared about the game. I gained the power to dodge bullets, and eventually, to see the future, and I did ultimately win. It was the best I've ever played the game, and a lifetime top 10 video game moment experientially.
My tentative model of this parent experience you're talking about is something like, if that story just kept going, instead of being about a particular instance of babysitting which has since ended. Curious if this resonates with anything that the kidhavers remember from The Before Time.
OK, I'm glad you replied with this, because I think maybe I was zooming in on the wrong thing. I was kind of thinking of "protecc smol" as being the Parent Thing but maybe a better babysitting anecdote would be something like this:
When I was a teenager, perhaps about two years older than my nephew is now, I was playing Super Street Fighter II Turbo on the SNES, with the secret code I will remember until the day I die (down R up L Y B) unlocking even higher speeds than the already unusually high speed of the game. I generally played it on max difficulty, ... (read more)
Before I became a parent I cared about children in general, intellectually, in the same way that I care about people in general: a general sense that I want good things to happen to them. Over the first few days of Lily's life, however, I noticed I cared for her deeply and emotionally, where her wellbeing was incredibly important to me, and she was far more cuddly and interesting than I expected. Over the next few months, I realized that my disposition toward children in general had also changed, and while I didn't feel as strongly as toward my own, they were now similarly far more fun, interesting, and precious than they had been. I also started having strong emotional reactions to reading about harm to children. Paul Graham writes about a similar experience, though I think one a bit more sudden than my own:
And Maia commenting on a post of Julia's:
In deciding to have kids this is a very difficult factor to consider, because it doesn't happen to everyone. I have a vague impression that it is a bit more common in men than women, perhaps because women understandably have a higher threshold for deciding to have kids, but there are definitely men who expect it to happen and are dismayed when it doesn't and women who are surprised at how much their feelings toward children change.
Getting better at predicting this transformation seems valuable: since becoming a parent is a lifelong decision, the value of information is really high. Do people tend to have similar experiences to their own parents? Is it correlated with any other aspects of personality? Can your friends or other people who know you well predict this? Can it be triggered, if it's going to, by something less permanent than becoming a parent or is the permanence a key component? Is it something that may or may not happen, and when it happens it is a similar magnitude for everyone, or is it something where most people change a bit on becoming a parent, anywhere along a range from "imperceptibly" to "enormously"? Do we know how prevalent these changes are?