Okay, I also spent some separate time on trying to game this out, I can't check with your previous GPT-5 conversation (seems like it's been deleted?) but I'll report what I thought of, and what Opus 5 & Opus 5.5 calculated & informed me of, after a bunch of back & forth.
① I hoped one would be able to use stars as gravitational lenses, apparently with a specific target there is a focal half-line (the signal should be on the line between emitter and lens). But: The sun only works as a lens from ~550 AU distance, so we'd have to put a fission reactor+a SOTA laser up there, Claude estimates it'd cost ~$80B and take more than two decades. Infeasible.
②If one used the second nearest star as a lens, then the signal would just sweep over the firmament unless we could get the laser to move in tandem, which would mean a hundred billion dollar reactor+laser satellite again.
③ One really wants to use pulsed lasers as emitters, not radio waves, because lasers have a narrow beam and little thermal noise interfering at it from the CMB, aiming away from the galactic plane to avoid dust.
④ One can't aim at a specific galaxy, as apparently we can't predict the movement of galaxies (and they do move, at on-the-order-of a few hundreds km/s, so over ~2Gyr it's a movement of multiple Mlyr, multiple times the width of the galaxy). This is surprising to me, since we can predict the aggregate flow of galaxies, e.g. the dipole repeller or virgocentric flow, but not for individual galaxies at the level of accuracy we need.
⑤ One can aim as to not shoot ones signal into intergalactic voids, but instead into galaxy clusters, as there's a 500× difference in the density of galaxies between voids and clusters. At the relevant grabby aliens distance there's some candidate clusters, e.g. the Abell clusters (e.g. 1689 or 2218, both at ~2.3 Glyr). Claude claims there's a few hundred candidates in total. (Aiming still only improves chances by 1.2–1.5×, apparently)
⑥ All in all, a small Claude-written estimational program gives a probability of reception of ~18% after spending ≲$1B, with a 1Hz laser aimed at a galaxy cluster, beamed from the ground (going to orbit reduces noise, but is much more expensive, so probably not). So a MB for a galaxy cluster is absolutely possible, for the 1Hz laser in 9 days; at 100 Hz you can get 100 clusters in ~9 days. Claude claims that repeatedly sending a message to the same cluster beats sending the same message to different clusters.
⑦ On the receiving side one needs
There's a bunch more detail here around where to get the laser parts (annoying but looks potentially doable), telescope (appears to be the biggest bottleneck), and power on a mountain top (gas turbines for 30MW are enough), but my impression is that one could have an installation sending out bits within half a year if one applies very strong urgency towards setting it up. Hm.
(This is me trying to condense about 3 hrs of Claude-wrangling into something comprehensible, hope it succeeded.)
Edit: I let Claude write a cost-analysis, which comes out at only $5M – $10M for sending several hundred 1MB messages (so a bunch cheaper than the initial estimate of almost a billion dollars!), with median 18 months time to first bit for a greenfield project, and 15 months for the brownfield (e.g. using existing buildings in locations that allow for telescopes with laser transmissions in e.g. Hawaii).
Firstly, let me be clear: I do not want to signal my pessimism, nor do I think that everything is that hopeless with AI. But I do think that the question of "what useful things can be done even if we accept the premise that AI-induced extinction is inevitably coming?" is worth being considered, and it would be pretty awkward if the world ends indeed and everyone realises that no one has really asked this question before (maybe someone did, let me know if it is the case).
Secondly, as you will see, I suggest some potential things to do, trying to answer this question. This is meant to be an illustration and a kind of proof-of-concept. Probably, many of these ideas do not make sense. However, it is not obvious to me that there are no useful ideas that can be invented in this regard if some people think relatively hard. Even the ideas I describe do not sound totally hopeless to me.
There are many alignment plans, but now I want to talk about plan E, where E stands for extinction.
The physics lever
Speed-of-light is a wall. An adversary with arbitrary local power cannot retroactively retrieve photons that have already left our future light cone. That observation makes a narrow window valuable: whatever we want preserved must be radiated now, redundantly, and in a form that minds unlike ours can decode with high probability. The useful direction is not “build a grand vault” but “broadcast a self-bootstrapping curriculum until the last switch flips.” The ASI can stop new transmissions and can chase old ones, but it will always be running behind the shell.
The hope is that somewhere—another biological civilisation, a better AI, a far-future archeologist, or even a simulator filtering on moral —someone receives a clean, self-describing record of who we were and what we cared about. If only one such receiver exists in our future light cone, and if only one of our transmissions decodes, that still changes how much of human value reaches the wider universe.
The logic and morality lever
It does not sound very promising, but we could probably focus on creating messages for transmission that, even if unreliably, demonstrate our niceness to other potential agents out there that are also nice. Something that we ourselves would consider nice, upon receiving. Ideally, of course, we could aim for some logical coordination, precommitments, acausal trade, verification, and the stuff, but I do not know how to do it.
But what is feasible is to send the messages simply claiming that we are sentient, we want to be reconstructed, and we adhere to these principles (among others):
Additionally, if we have an opportunity, we could add an alignment failure report (what we tried; where it broke), not to impress anyone, but to show we prefer truthful accounting over PR.
This doesn’t prove anything for other agents, but even so, nice agents could respond to it.
The welfare lever
There is still the matter of how the story ends. Even if the interval between “it starts” and “it finishes” is short, it will contain a great deal of potential suffering. Here, usefulness looks unromantic: palliative protocols optimized for scarcity; clear, open instructions for pain control, psychological first aid, dignified rituals, and ways for families to connect when infrastructure disappears; “humane shutdown” procedures for captive animals and facilities that would otherwise produce prolonged harm if abandoned; conflict dampers and ceasefire compacts that shift the default away from last-mile violence over dwindling resources. None of this requires coordination with a hostile superintelligence. All of it is compressible into leaflets, sms-length snippets, and audio recordings that can be pre-positioned.
If you think this is performative, notice that, conditional on doom, marginal suffering averted per dollar here is extraordinarily high, and conditional on survival, you’ve just improved emergency preparedness.
Hopelessness does not necessarily mean Plan E is the only reasonable option
On a more positive note:
As I stated in the beginning, I do not think everything is hopeless, but that is up to you to decide. Maybe it is or maybe it will be.
However, even if we accept the most radical doomerism and if things look hopeless in this timeline, work on AI safety still sort of makes sense under a Many-Worlds lens. Our choices still can increase the share (measure) of branches where alignment succeeds or the ending is kinder—even if our own branch still loses.
It seems correct to claim that safety research, governance pressure, and AI pause activism still push a little more weight toward good outcomes across near-identical histories. That may be a real impact, even if we never get to live in one of those branches. This, of course, triggers the entire discussion on Many-Worlds and the stuff, but I skip it.
What I’m explicitly not proposing
I’m not proposing “hide the seeds on the Moon,” “bury tungsten slates in the Atacama,” or “launch a thousand postcards toward Alpha Cen.” Under the assumed threat model, a decisive optimiser sweeps the Solar System; anything we can reach, it can reach faster and more thoroughly. Nor am I proposing elaborate active beacons that depend on long-term maintenance. Plan E is not about artifacts that can be confiscated, it’s about structures that have already left or minimising suffering pre-singularity.
I am also not necessarily claiming that some fraction of people should pivot to Plan E. But I think it is worth thinking about.