Thoughts about intelligence.
My hope is that some altruistic person will read this comment, see where I am wrong and point me to the literature I need to read. Thanks in advance.
I've been thinking about the problem of general intelligence. Before going too deeply I wanted to see if I had a handle on what intelligence is period.
It seems to me that the people sitting in the library with me now are intelligent and that my pencil is not. So what is the minimum my pencil would have to do before I suddenly thought that it was intelligent?
Moving alone doesn't count. If I drop the pencil it will fall towards the table. You could say that I caused the pencil to move, but I am not sure this isn't begging the question.
Now suppose the first time I dropped the pencil and it fell to the floor. Now I go to drop it a second time but I do it over the table. However, the pencil flies around the table and hits the same spot on the floor.
Now its got my attention. But maybe its something about the table. So I drop the pencil but put my hand in the way. Still the pencil goes around my hand.
I put my foot over the spot on the floor and drop the pencil. It flies around my foot and then into the crevice between my foot and the floor and gets stuck. As soon as I lift my foot the pencil goes to the same spot.
I believe I should now conclude that my pencil is intelligent. This has something to do with the following facts.
1) The pencil kept going to the same spot as if it had a "goal"
2) The pencil was able to respond to "obstacles" in ways not predicted by my original simply theory of pencil behavior.
I believe that I would say the pencil is more intelligent if it could pass through more "complicated" obstacles.
Here are some of my basic problems
1) What is a "goal" beyond what my intuition says
2) Similarly what is an "obstacle"
3) And what is "complicated"
I have some sense that "obstacle" is related to reducing the probability that the goal will be reached
I have some s that complicated has to do with the degree to which the probability is reduced.
Thoughts? Suggestions for readings?
You are talking about control systems.
A control system has two inputs (called its "perception" and "reference") and one output. The perception is a signal coming from the environment, and the output is a signal that has an effect on the environment. For artificial control systems, the reference is typically set by a human operator; for living systems it is typically set within the organism.
What makes it a control system is that firstly, the output has an effect, via the environment, on the perception, and secondly, the feedback loop thu... (read more)
We've had these for a year, I'm sure we all know what to do by now.
This thread is for the discussion of Less Wrong topics that have not appeared in recent posts. If a discussion gets unwieldy, celebrate by turning it into a top-level post.