So, if you've been reading my Less Wrong posts over the last twenty-one months, you'll notice that I've been doing a lot of philosophy-of-language blogging lately! Those posts are:
But, if you didn't know, the reason I've been doing so much philosophy-of-language blogging lately is because I was frustrated because I thought a lot of people were motivatedly getting the philosophy of language wrong for political convenience, specifically around transgender issues. (I think assertions like "trans women are women" and similar need to be argued for on the empirical merits; you can't just define them to be true.)
In particular, "Where to Draw the Boundaries?" was intended as a "stealth reply" (quoting/paraphrasing without attribution in order to reply to the philosophical substance while eliding the political context) to:
I also write a blog about gender issues under a differential-visibility-but-not-actually-Secret pen name. The posts from that blog that are most relevant to my philosophical writing on Less Wrong are:
you mostly address the rationalist community, and Bailey mostly addresses GCs and HBDs, and so on. So "most people you encounter using that term on Twitter" doesn't refer to irrelevant outsiders, it refers to the people you're trying to have the conversation with
That makes sense as a critique of my or Bailey's writing, but "Davis and Bailey's writing is unclear and arguably deceptive given their target audience's knowledge" is a very different claim than "autogynephilia is not a natural abstraction"!!
I think you naturally thought of autogynephilia and gender progressivism as being more closely related than they really are
That makes sense as a critique of my or Bailey's writing, but "Davis and Bailey's writing is unclear and arguably deceptive given their target audience's knowledge" is a very different claim than "autogynephilia is not a natural abstraction"!!
More specifically, I believe that the reason your and Bailey's writing is unclear given the target audience's knowledge is because the audience lacks the knowledge needed for autogynephilia to be a natural abstraction. And my claim "autogynephilia is not a natural abstraction" is not primarily critiquing you or Bailey... (read more)
So, if you've been reading my Less Wrong posts over the last twenty-one months, you'll notice that I've been doing a lot of philosophy-of-language blogging lately! Those posts are:
(forthcoming)But, if you didn't know, the reason I've been doing so much philosophy-of-language blogging lately is because I was frustrated because I thought a lot of people were motivatedly getting the philosophy of language wrong for political convenience, specifically around transgender issues. (I think assertions like "trans women are women" and similar need to be argued for on the empirical merits; you can't just define them to be true.)
In particular, "Where to Draw the Boundaries?" was intended as a "stealth reply" (quoting/paraphrasing without attribution in order to reply to the philosophical substance while eliding the political context) to:
I also write a blog about gender issues under a differential-visibility-but-not-actually-Secret pen name. The posts from that blog that are most relevant to my philosophical writing on Less Wrong are:
To allay concerns about premature abstraction of political issues, I'm putting up this non-Frontpageable post in case anyone wants to comment on or ask questions about my object-level motivations without cluttering up our philosophy discussions.