I've also reflected on "microhabits" – I agree that the epistemics are tricky, of maintaining a habit even when you can't observe causal evidence for it being beneficial. I'll implement a habit if I've read some of the evidence and think it's worth the cost, even if I don't observe any effect in myself. Unfortunately, that's the same mistake homeopathics make.
I'm motivated to follow microhabitats mostly out of faith that they have some latent effects, but also out of a subconscious desire to uphold my identity, like what James Clear talks about in Atomic Habits.
Like when I take a vitamin D supplement in the morning, I'm not subconsciously thinking "oh man, the subtle effects this might have on my circadian rhythm and mood are totally worth the minimal cost!". Instead, it's more like "I'm taking this supplement because that's what a thoughtful person who cares about their cognitive health does. This isn't a chore; it's a part of what it means to live Roman's life".
Here's a list of some of my other microhabits (that weren't mentioned in your post) in case anyone's looking for inspiration. Or maybe I'm just trying to affirm my identity? ;P
I haven't noticed any significant difference from any of these habits individually. But, like you suggested, I've found success with throwing many things at the wall: it used to take me a long time to fall asleep, and now it doesn't. Unfortunately, I don't know what microhabits did the trick (stuck to the wall).
It seems like there are three types of habits that require some faith:
This is my fifth attempt at writing this post. I’m starting to think that I’ve already spent way too much time on this topic, which I’m convinced is valuable, but maybe not so valuable as to spend 20 hours perpetually rewriting a post about it. So obviously my solution is to rewrite it again, but this time in bullet points.
Here’s a tl;dr: There are some habits people can pick up that are very cheap, and may have positive effects, but these effects are too small to reliably notice consciously. Hence these habits are often neglected. In this post I argue to take some of these habits more seriously, and if they’re low-cost enough for you to implement, stick to them even absent of any feeling of them being useful.
Some Anecdotes
Final Remark
One could argue this post argues in favor of bad epistemics. There’s a lot of potential placebo effects going on here, particularly in my anecdotes, and it’s unclear if any of these are really linked to actual effects, and if the causality is remotely close to what I suggest. There’s some risk of self deception that should be avoided.
I would agree with this viewpoint, but would also add that this post is less about finding true facts about the world, and much more about finding ways to optimize one’s own personal daily life that actually work – and if these ways happen to rest partially on placebo effects and/or incorrect assessments, then I’m fine with that as long at the overall impact is positive. If you find ways to implement five micro habits at near-zero cost to you, only two of which are load-bearing and actually improve your life while the other three are neutral, that to me still seems like a win, and it may well be the case that just sticking to this routine is a better option than to invest more effort into trying to figure out the actual truth about which of these useful and which are not.