LESSWRONG
LW

World Modeling
Frontpage

17

Distinguishing logistic curves: visual

by Stuart_Armstrong
15th May 2020
1 min read
0

17

World Modeling
Frontpage

17

New Comment
Moderation Log
More from Stuart_Armstrong
View more
Curated and popular this week
0Comments

I wrote a post about distinguishing between logistic curves, specifically for finding their turning points.

That post was highly mathematical; but here is a visual "proof" of the "theorem":

  • Figuring out the turning point of a logistic curve before hitting that turning point is bloody hard, mate.

"Proof": The following is a plot two curves:

  1. The logistic curve 1/(1+e−x) up to its turning point at x=0.
  2. The exponential curve 0.51e0.69x, which never has any turning points.

So, if the data was noisy, could you distinguish between the curve that's reached its turning point, and the one that will never have one?

Things get even worse if we stop before the turning point; here's the plot of the logistic curve up to x=−log(3)≈−0.48, with the y=0.25 being half of the value at the turning point. This is plotted against the exponential 0.64e0.85x:

Mentioned in
112Extrapolating GPT-N performance
24Distinguishing logistic curves