What is going on with this post? You say it's a brief intro to section 3, but section 3 of what? I find your intro very confusing so I'm not sure if I should be diving into the post to figure out what it offers.
I suggest you clarify, unless I'm missing something incredibly obvious...
Of the sequence/website 'thermontology'. Click the linked post or browse the rest of the sequence.
If you won't bother telling me what this relates to at the start of your post, then no I'm not going to spend time figuring it out. And I assume that's going to be the response of 99% of your readers, which is why I said something instead of just asked Claude to tell me what the hell is going on in case you've got something I care about in there. As is, I assume it's only for people already invested enough to recognize either of those posts (I did read Kaj's review but don't remember it clearly as being super valuable) I'm busy, just like everyone reading LW. Conscious vs unconscious processing and how to think about it is an interest of mine, but I'm busy and rarely find work that's clarifying vs the massive amount I've already read.
Saying what a post offers at the top seems like just basic good writing. This has become my bugaboo so sorry to be a stickler about it. I'll try to come back and at least look when I have time even if you don't say anything more.
eh? I just explained what it relates to, I'm introducing section 3 of the larger sequence. But yeah feel free not to read it if you don't want to.
Just trying to be helpful. See my edits above. I assume that other readers will have similar confusions, and that you'll get a lot more readers if you start each post by saying what it offers in a form a new reader can understand. I'm also assuming that you actually want more people to read it.
Sorry to be a bit titchy, good luck and I'll try to come back and figure it out myself if I get time.
No worries. I expanded the intro a bit to explicitly refer to the sequence/website.
[LW Meta: this post is essentially (a) brief intro to section 3 of the 'thermontology' sequence/website (b) a meta-summary of Kaj's post Book Summary: Consciousness and the Brain ]
3.0 Now let's talk about higher-level things than physics!
3.0.1 I'm going to write about a seemingly random collection of things in the biological and social worlds, connected by three themes:
3.0.2 As you might guess, I ultimately want to analogize these things to the phenomena in physics from the last section. Just to clear up any confusion, I'm not claiming that social networks use quantum entanglement to function or something like that. It's more of a structural analogy. I'll get more into this in section 4.
3.1 Amplification in the Brain
3.1.0.1 What is consciousness and how does it relate to the brain? This question has baffled philosophers for centuries. Tabling the philosophical questions about what consciousness even is, though, neuroscience has actually made a lot of progress on a more well-defined question: what's the difference between the processing in the brain of which people are aware, and that which they are not aware of?
3.1.0.2 The material in this section is shamelessly stolen from Kaj Sotala's excellent post Book Summary: Consciousness and the Brain. The rest of his Multiagent Models of Mind sequence is excellent too.
3.1.1 Conscious and Unconscious Processing
3.1.1.1 It's clear that people aren't conscious of almost all of the processing that's going on in their brain. The brain contains ~10^11 neurons and ~10^15 synapses. Each neuron fires about once per second. Obviously we aren't aware of almost any of this. On the other hand, we do have awareness of some things, such as the content of our visual fields.
3.1.1.2 Wait, how do we even define aware? Let's say that people are consciously aware of things that they can verbally report.
3.1.1.3 So what determines the difference between things people are aware of and things they aren't? Neuroscientists have carried out a series of ingenious experiments to determine the boundary between these things.
3.1.1.4 The basic idea is as follows. If you very rapidly turn certain stimuli on and then off, people aren't able to notice that they were there at all. However, you can determine that some part of their brain processed the stimulus, because their performance on tasks related to the stimulus improves.
3.1.1.5 One basic paradigm in these experiments is visual masking. A subject is told to look at a screen on which various geometric shapes are shown[1]. For a very brief interval, the shapes are replaced with some sort of meaningful stimulus such as the word "radio". By controlling the interval for which the stimulus is shown, researchers can control how often subjects report seeing it. If the word is shown for 40ms, nobody sees it; at 50ms, about half can see it.
Figure: A masking experiment. Subjects are shown a screen containing a rapid series of random geometric shapes. A meaningful stimulus such as a word is briefly flashed on the screen. From here.
3.1.1.6 Priming experiments show that the subject's brain has nevertheless processed the word, even if they aren't consciously aware of it. The idea is to give subjects a task to complete about 1 second after the word is shown. For instance, after the word "radio" is flashed, subjects might be shown the word "house" and asked to classify it as either a living thing or an object. If the word the subjects are shown is the same as the flashed "priming" word, they are quicker to classify it.
3.1.1.7 Unconscious processing goes beyond mere visual similarity. For instance, the uppercase "RADIO" helps to speed up processing lowercase "radio", although they have very different visual appearances. And contrarily, "ANGER" does not speed up "RANGE", although they have the same letters, suggesting that the meaning of the words is important for the unconscious processing. Quite complex processing can happen without awareness: for instance, chess masters shown a chess position can more quickly classify the position as a check if they are primed with the same position.
3.1.1.8 Besides speeding up conscious decisions, unconscious information can also be used to guide decisions directly, and for learning. In one experiment subjects were tasked with pressing or not pressing a button after being shown a signal (the signal giving no information about which choice was correct). Choosing correctly earned them money. The signals were preceded by briefly-flashed masked shapes which indicated whether pressing or not pressing was the correct response. Although the shapes were shown too briefly to register in consciousness, subjects learned to choose correctly at a better-than-chance rate.
3.1.1.9 So unconscious processing can do a lot. Besides verbal report, what does conscious processing add?
3.1.1.10 One other set of experiments people ran concerned the rivalrous nature of consciousness; in other words, consciousness can only strongly focus on one thing at a time. People are shown a series of digits into which 2 letters are inserted. They're told to remember the letters; if the letters are shown too quickly after each other, they may not even notice that the second letter was present. Focusing on the first letter prevents the second from entering consciousness.
3.1.1.11 So that's a brief overview of some experimental evidence we have regarding conscious and unconscious processing. Given this, what can we say about how they are implemented in the brain?
3.1.2 The Global Neuronal Workspace
3.1.2.1 People have run variants of the masking experiments above where they (a) hook up the subjects to an apparatus for measuring brain activity, such as an MRI, EEG, or MEG, and (b) intentionally vary the length of the stimuli presented so that some of the stimuli reach consciousness. Then researchers try to identify differences in brain activity between conscious and unconscious perception.
3.1.2.2 The basic result people have found is that consciousness of a stimulus happens when the neural signal associated with the stimulus exceeds a threshold and is amplified and spreads to distant regions of the brain, whereas unconscious stimuli's signals remain localized to a particular part of the brain and fade away.
3.1.2.3 How does this amplification take place? There are various long-range interconnections between different regions of the cortex. These interconnections feed back on each other, and when a given signal becomes strong enough it can kick off a self-reinforcing loop that eventually synchronizes a large part of the brain on processing the given signal.
Figure: The global neuronal workspace. The strength of an incoming signal determines if it is strong enough to propagate to the self-reinforcing loops of the GNW. From here.
3.1.2.4 This is called the "global neuronal workspace". Aside from the cortex, the GNW also connects to the basal ganglia, thalamus, hippocampus, and other parts of the brain. The GNW theory of consciousness posits that the contents of consciousness are precisely the things that the GNW is processing in a given moment.
3.1.2.5 The GNW explains various features of consciousness:
3.1.2.6 So what's the biological function of consciousness? There are probably a few. Here are some speculations.
The purpose of the shapes is to prevent subjects from noticing a small flicker when the word appears, as might happen if the screen was black.