"Why didn't you challenge anybody else to write up a list like that, if you wanted to make a point of nobody else being able to write it?" I was asked.
Because I don't actually think it does any good, or persuades anyone of anything, people don't like tests like that, and I don't really believe in them myself either. I couldn't pass a test somebody else invented around something they found easy to do, for many such possible tests.
But people asked, so, fine, let's actually try it this time. Maybe I'm wrong about how bad things are, and will be pleasantly surprised. If I'm never pleasantly surprised then I'm obviously not being pessimistic enough yet.
So: As part of my current fiction-writing project, I'm currently writing a list of some principles that dath ilan's Basement-of-the-World project has invented for describing AGI corrigibility - the sort of principles you'd build into a Bounded Thing meant to carry out some single task or task-class and not destroy the world by doing it.
So far as I know, every principle of this kind, except for Jessica Taylor's "quantilization", and "myopia" (not sure who correctly named this as a corrigibility principle), was invented by myself; eg "low impact", "shutdownability". (Though I don't particularly think it hopeful if you claim that somebody else has publication priority on "low impact" or whatevs, in some stretched or even nonstretched way; ideas on the level of "low impact" have always seemed cheap to me to propose, harder to solve before the world ends.)
Some of the items on dath ilan's upcoming list out of my personal glowfic writing have already been written up more seriously by me. Some haven't.
I'm writing this in one afternoon as one tag in my cowritten online novel about a dath ilani who landed in a D&D country run by Hell. One and a half thousand words or so, maybe. (2169 words.)
How about you try to do better than the tag overall, before I publish it, upon the topic of corrigibility principles on the level of "myopia" for AGI? It'll get published in a day or so, possibly later, but I'm not going to be spending more than an hour or two polishing it.
[Hi! Been lurking for a long time, this seems like as good a reason as any to actually put something out there. Epistemic status: low confidence but it seems low risk high reward to try. not intended to be a full list, I do not have the expertise for that, I am just posting any ideas at all that I have and don't already see here. this probably already exists and I just don't know the name.]
1) input masking, basically for oracle/task-AI you ask the AI for a program that solves a slightly more general version of your problem and don't give the AI the information necessary to narrow it down, then run the program on your actual case (+ probably some simple test cases you know the answer to to make sure it solves the problem). this lets you penalize the AI for complexity of the output program and therefore it will give you something narrow instead of a general reasoner. (obviously you still have to be sensible about the output program, don't go post the code to github or give it internet access.)
2) reward function stability. we know we might have made mistakes inputting the reward function, but we have some example test cases we're confident in. tell the AI to look for a bunch of different possible functions that give the same output as the existing reward function, and filter potential actions by whether any of those see them as harmful.
The top-rated comment on "AGI Ruin: A List of Lethalities" claims that many other people could've written a list like that.
"Why didn't you challenge anybody else to write up a list like that, if you wanted to make a point of nobody else being able to write it?" I was asked.
Because I don't actually think it does any good, or persuades anyone of anything, people don't like tests like that, and I don't really believe in them myself either. I couldn't pass a test somebody else invented around something they found easy to do, for many such possible tests.
But people asked, so, fine, let's actually try it this time. Maybe I'm wrong about how bad things are, and will be pleasantly surprised. If I'm never pleasantly surprised then I'm obviously not being pessimistic enough yet.
So: As part of my current fiction-writing project, I'm currently writing a list of some principles that dath ilan's Basement-of-the-World project has invented for describing AGI corrigibility - the sort of principles you'd build into a Bounded Thing meant to carry out some single task or task-class and not destroy the world by doing it.
So far as I know, every principle of this kind, except for Jessica Taylor's "quantilization", and "myopia" (not sure who correctly named this as a corrigibility principle), was invented by myself; eg "low impact", "shutdownability". (Though I don't particularly think it hopeful if you claim that somebody else has publication priority on "low impact" or whatevs, in some stretched or even nonstretched way; ideas on the level of "low impact" have always seemed cheap to me to propose, harder to solve before the world ends.)
Some of the items on dath ilan's upcoming list out of my personal glowfic writing have already been written up more seriously by me. Some haven't.
I'm writing this in one afternoon as one tag in my cowritten online novel about a dath ilani who landed in a D&D country run by Hell.
One and a half thousand words or so, maybe. (2169 words.)How about you try to do better than the tag overall, before I publish it, upon the topic of corrigibility principles on the level of "myopia" for AGI? It'll get published in a day or so, possibly later, but I'm not going to be spending more than an hour or two polishing it.