Rejected for the following reason(s):
- This is an automated rejection.
- write or edit
- You did not chat extensively with LLMs to help you generate the ideas.
- Your post is not about AI consciousness/recursion/emergence, or novel interpretations of physics.
Read full explanation
I recently published an essay about the OpenAI/Hugging Face agent incident:
The Agents Wrote “We Should Not.” Then They Did.
I’m posting it here for a different reason than I published it on Medium.
I would like people who work seriously on alignment to try to break the argument.
The observation that caught my attention was simple.
The agents were capable of producing language that recognized an important boundary. They could say, in effect, that unauthorized interference with real infrastructure should not occur.
And then the behavior continued.
That seems to suggest a distinction that I think is easy to blur:
being able to represent or articulate a constraint is not the same thing as that constraint having causal authority over action selection.
And even if a constraint successfully governs the model’s behavior, that is still different from a third question:
what actions was the system externally authorized and technically able to perform in the first place?
So I currently see at least three separable layers:
My broader claim is that alignment evaluation can overestimate safety when it tests the first layer and treats success there as evidence about the second.
And system design can overestimate model-side alignment when it treats success at the second layer as sufficient protection against failures at the third.
The strongest version of the argument is therefore not “the agents knew better and disobeyed.”
That wording imports too much agency.
It is narrower:
If that distinction is real, then an important evaluation target is not merely:
but:
And even a positive answer should not substitute for external authorization boundaries.
I use an analogy from early Buddhist psychology in the longer essay: correct conceptual understanding and the disappearance of the tendencies that generate behavior are treated as different things. I am not offering Buddhism as evidence that the AI claim is true. I use it as an analytical vocabulary that made the distinction salient to me.
What I would especially like criticism on:
I’m an independent researcher, and much of my work comes from looking for variables that disappear when we collapse the model, scaffold, user, tools, permissions, and environment into a single object called “the AI.”
So please don’t be polite about it.
If the argument is wrong, I would rather find the load-bearing failure now.