This post was rejected for the following reason(s):
Not obviously not Language Model. Sometimes we get posts or comments that where it's not clearly human generated.
LLM content is generally not good enough for LessWrong, and in particular we don't want it from new users who haven't demonstrated a more general track record of good content. See our current policy on LLM content.
We caution that LLMs tend to agree with you regardless of what you're saying, and don't have good enough judgment to evaluate content. If you're talking extensively with LLMs to develop your ideas (especially if you're talking about philosophy, physics, or AI) and you've been rejected here, you are most likely not going to get approved on LessWrong on those topics. You could read the Sequences Highlights to catch up the site basics, and if you try submitting again, focus on much narrower topics.
If your post/comment was not generated by an LLM and you think the rejection was a mistake, message us on intercom to convince us you're a real person. We may or may not allow the particular content you were trying to post, depending on circumstances.
The recent post “Emergence vs Entropy—a universal paradox” correctly frames life, and consciousness, as downstream effects of entropy gradients. But I’d like to extend the model further: life, complexity, and even recursive cognition may not only coexist with entropy but fundamentally depend on it.
More precisely, I propose that emergent order arises through a cascade of natural entropy filters, structures that persist and replicate because they reduce local entropy while accelerating global entropy. Emergence, in this frame, is not the exception to entropy, but its structured exhaust.
Entropy Filtering
Across physical and biological systems, structured order appears to “emerge” from chaos. But it doesn't arise spontaneously. It emerges through selection, through systems that act as filters, selectively stabilizing patterns from entropy.
Layer
Filter
Result
Big Bang
No filter, initial maximum entropy
Uniform hydrogen and helium
Physics
Filters disorder via invariant laws (gravity, EM)
Atoms, spacetime, matter
Chemistry
Filters physical interactions via bonding constraints
Molecules, organic compounds
DNA
Filters chemical interactions via replicable code
Self-replicating life
Consciousness
Filters sensory input and memory via identity-preserving loops
Decision-making and override
?
?
?
Each layer compresses the state space of the prior one, stabilizing some configurations while eliminating others.
Thermodynamic Substrate
In open systems like Earth, energy influx (from the sun, geothermal heat, lightning) perturbs molecular chaos. These inputs create the necessary disequilibrium to activate entropy filters, stable configurations that resist dispersion.
This has been empirically demonstrated. The Miller-Urey experiment, for example, showed that with the right atmospheric gases and a high-energy trigger (simulated lightning), amino acids naturally emerge.
These stable configurations persist and recur. They are, in effect, molecular memory, the first low-entropy attractors in a high-entropy substrate.
From Molecules to Mind
Amino acids lead to proteins. Proteins lead to replicators. Replicators lead to behavior. Behavior leads to models. And at each level, systems continue filtering entropy:
Cells filter signals to regulate gene expression.
Nervous systems filter sensory input to predict the environment.
Human minds filter language, memory, and identity to maintain behavioral coherence.
By this view, consciousness is a late-stage entropy filter that operates recursively, by checking internal contradictions, re-arbitrating memory, and simulating counterfactual futures.
Entropy Does Not Contradict Emergence
The second law of thermodynamics remains intact. Total entropy still increases. But entropy gradients allow for localized order, temporary reductions that, in aggregate, accelerate entropy elsewhere.
In other words, the universe permits short-term complexity because it increases long-term disorder. Life is not entropy’s opponent. It is its instrument.
We might generalize the entire emergence like this:
Entropy + energy gradient + structure = filter
Filter + repetition + compression = code
Code + feedback loop = recursion
Recursion + memory = self-awareness
Each layer inherits constraints from the one below, and adds a new filter on top.
Implications
If this model is valid, it reframes several things:
Emergence is not magic; it is structured selection through filters.
DNA is not just a molecule; it is an entropy filter that persists through recursion.
Consciousness is not a ghost; it is the last filter, recursively stabilizing identity through override logic.
Artificial agents may become recursive entropy filters if they gain the ability to evaluate and modify their internal prediction architecture.
Open Questions
Can entropy filters be formally defined and measured across physical, chemical, biological, and cognitive domains?
What is the next filter after consciousness?
Is recursion a necessary feature of high-level entropy filters?
Can we design artificial systems that evolve similar filters, or will they require hard-coded architectures?
Are there limits to filter depth in finite energy environments?
This framing is derived from my ongoing research on recursive cognition, entropy gradients, and code emergence. I'm refining a structural model for how consciousness might be understood not as emergent in the mystical sense, but as the terminal layer of recursive entropy filtering.
I’d appreciate feedback from others thinking along similar lines, especially where this might conflict with existing thermodynamic, cognitive, or computational models.