Good objection to accepting that a conjecture is unprovable without proof.
Though not a good objection to accepting it's probably true and moving on to work on more fruitful stuff. Do you have a theory of productivity in mathematics? (In undergrad I never encountered one, the stance seemed to be "don't think too hard about usefulness or else you might fall out of pure mathematics and into physics or engineering. Anyway, it's basically random. There's just no way to estimate the usefulness of any given theorem! It's all fine! Follow your heart! (into my phd programme)") Do you have an argument against empirical mathematics? (Something like "stable probabilities for proof outcomes are difficult, even for reasonable people, to agree on". Afaik this is just not a question people have been asking.)
As a companion to the Specificity Sequence, heres's a place to share memorable examples of examples from your life or from popular culture.