I think a lot of people have heard so much about internalized prejudice and bias that they think they should ignore any bad vibes they get about a person that they can’t rationally explain.
But if a person gives you a bad feeling, don’t ignore that.
Both I and several others who I know have generally come to regret it if they’ve gotten a bad feeling about somebody and ignored it or rationalized it away.
I’m not saying to endorse prejudice. But my experience is that many types of prejudice feel more obvious. If someone has an accent that I associate with something negative, it’s usually pretty obvious to me that it’s their accent that I’m reacting to.
Of course, not everyone has the level of reflectivity to make that distinction. But if you have thoughts like “this person gives me a bad vibe but maybe that’s just my internalized prejudice and I should ignore it”, then you probably have enough metacognition to also notice if there’s any clear trait you’re prejudiced about, and whether you would feel the same way about other people with that trait.
Naturally, “don’t ignore the bad feeling” also doesn’t mean “actively shun and be a jerk toward them”. If they’re a coworker and you need to collaborate with them, then sure, do what’s expected of you. And sometimes people do get a bad first impression of someone that then gets better – if the bad feeling naturally melts away on its own, that’s fine.
But if you’re currently getting a bad feeling about someone and they make a bid for something on top of normal interaction… like if they ask you out or to join a new business venture or if you’re just considering sharing something private with them… you might want to avoid that.
I don’t have any rigorous principled argument for this, other than just the empirical personal observation that ignoring the feeling usually seems to be a mistake.
Consider reversing this advice in the case where you tend to easily get a bad vibe from everyone. Anni Kanniainen comments:
I struggle with trauma-related trust issues, so sometimes I might get bad vibes merely due to my own withdrawn nature in the situation or the fact that I expect the worst from a situation — i.e. meeting with a lady during a weekend out and finding later that she’s approached me with a voice message, so I assume she’s yelling at me about something I had done wrong.
That being said, I think there is a genuine bad vibe you may sometimes get — and often it’s a calmer and more rational one that you would get with a gut-punch of anxiety. You notice it best by observing how an individual talks or behaves in a social context or by interpreting their current actions through the information you’ve already acquired.
This approach tends to work, but sometimes entertaining your intuitions only make the anxiety bigger.
As an another point in the opposite direction, I do also endorse the adage of trust beyond reason, as defined in that link – as long as you don’t get a bad vibe.
I am not an HR professional. This is all experience as manager/director/multiple business owner.
I worked at one big corporate (Capital One Bank) who had both very rigorous recruitment processes and had very comprehensive annual appraisal processes for employees - plus of course hard data like whether they made it through appraisal, how long they worked there, promotions etc. They did analysis (they are renowned for analysing everything), looking for correlations between scores of various bits of the recruitment process and the above outcomes. There is literature on this sort of thing as well, some of it of dubious quality.
But really if you did some or all the interviewing and were responsible for the hiring decision and then work with the person you hired then you often know within days or weeks whether the person is what you thought they would be. That's a generalisation and there are exceptions, there are people who are slow starters, a few who start well but have fatal flaws. But I would say with experience you can be confident 80% of the time, within two weeks of having either found someone really good, or bad enough you wish you hadn't hired them, or they are ok but not a superstar.
Clearly none of this covers the people you didn't hire. But again with experience, and having made mistakes, you get to see the correlations. between good/bad hires and what you saw at interview.
I think a lot of people have heard so much about internalized prejudice and bias that they think they should ignore any bad vibes they get about a person that they can’t rationally explain.
But if a person gives you a bad feeling, don’t ignore that.
Both I and several others who I know have generally come to regret it if they’ve gotten a bad feeling about somebody and ignored it or rationalized it away.
I’m not saying to endorse prejudice. But my experience is that many types of prejudice feel more obvious. If someone has an accent that I associate with something negative, it’s usually pretty obvious to me that it’s their accent that I’m reacting to.
Of course, not everyone has the level of reflectivity to make that distinction. But if you have thoughts like “this person gives me a bad vibe but maybe that’s just my internalized prejudice and I should ignore it”, then you probably have enough metacognition to also notice if there’s any clear trait you’re prejudiced about, and whether you would feel the same way about other people with that trait.
Naturally, “don’t ignore the bad feeling” also doesn’t mean “actively shun and be a jerk toward them”. If they’re a coworker and you need to collaborate with them, then sure, do what’s expected of you. And sometimes people do get a bad first impression of someone that then gets better – if the bad feeling naturally melts away on its own, that’s fine.
But if you’re currently getting a bad feeling about someone and they make a bid for something on top of normal interaction… like if they ask you out or to join a new business venture or if you’re just considering sharing something private with them… you might want to avoid that.
I don’t have any rigorous principled argument for this, other than just the empirical personal observation that ignoring the feeling usually seems to be a mistake.
Consider reversing this advice in the case where you tend to easily get a bad vibe from everyone. Anni Kanniainen comments:
As an another point in the opposite direction, I do also endorse the adage of trust beyond reason, as defined in that link – as long as you don’t get a bad vibe.