LESSWRONG
LW

Personal Blog

-1

Implications of a feelings-first metaphysics?

by efficientfox
18th Nov 2017
1 min read
2

-1

Personal Blog

-1

Implications of a feelings-first metaphysics?
1ryan_b
1DragonGod
New Comment
2 comments, sorted by
top scoring
Click to highlight new comments since: Today at 6:43 PM
[-]ryan_b8y10

A few questions leap to mind.

1) How are you accounting for the fact that people do not experience the same feelings? Even among neurotypicals, there is wide variation in the response to the same stimuli.

2) The second of your initial ideas - you believe what enables you to act - seems to assume a utilitarian perspective on belief. Is that right?

3) There is a heavy emphasis on language - are you including mathematics in that description? Other forms of communication? Ritualized experiences? What is it bounded by, if not by language?

4) What is the goal here?

5) If you don't have access to information outside of your feelings and these rules, how do you determine what actions make you feel a sense of balance?

Reply
[-]DragonGod8y10

What do you mean by "balance"?

Why optimise for the feeling of "balance"?

Reply
Moderation Log
More from efficientfox
View more
Curated and popular this week
2Comments

What would be the implications on decision-making, beliefs, and actions of a metaphysics that is structured as follows?:

  1. All beliefs, ideas, actions, etc. are driven by feelings.
  2. Reasons are descriptions of feelings.
  3. Language fails to fully capture the sensational qualities of feelings.
  4. Decision-making, belief adoption, etc. cannot be bounded by language.

Some initial ideas:

-I act in a way that makes me feel a sense of balance.

-I believe what enables me to act in a way that makes me feel a sense of balance.

-I structure my perception of the world, decisions, and actions out of this goal-driven pursuit of feeling a sense of balance.

-I do not have access to information/ideas/actions/etc outside of this.

Here is a map of what this would look like:

Emotional Awareness branches out into Balance and Map.

OODA loop connects emotional awareness to the ideas of balance and of a map. I observe how I feel (emotional awareness), orient my map to fit this feeling, decide how to act / what to believe / what information to take in based on how the map makes me feel that I would feel more balanced, and act in accordance with the decision.