It feels like the common man lost a bit of his soul after we exterminated the vast majority of organized crime. Yes, crime sucks. But even if these organizations were horrible for the communities they preyed on, the existence of an underbelly at least suggested limits to state power. There was an existence proof of people outside the state developing a (conditional, fictional) code of honor, and coordinating amongst themselves, in a way that was transgressive and competitive with the state, unlike the drugged-out homeless man yelling obscenities at you on the subway. People watching old movies and TV shows can feel the guilty exhilaration at the idea of participating in or shaping a network outside the state, with its own rules.
Nowadays even the petty crime you do witness feels like evidence of the state's taunting indifference. There are cameras on every street corner; every child grows up with the tacit knowledge that everything they've ever said or done is going to be logged in some government database searchable by AI. The "government", whatever that means, could stop the guy who's shitting on the subway, if it wanted to. Crime has stopped being something that happens in spite of the government, or undermines it, and started being another boring reminder of your powerlessness in the face of the reigning regime, and of how nobody can ever do anything about it.
I don't even know if removing the new technology enforcing the law would do anything. Today most of the public is so passive and demoralized that if you try to die for a cause they immediately start making debased edits of the video. It's just a dark joke, they'll say. But I don't think that people felt compelled to joke about it when they felt like there was something they could do to change their situation, when they felt like there was some organization that could evolve out of the chaos without being parasitized by social media. I read about events like the Romanian Revolution and it feels like I'm reading a fantasy novel. How did this happen forty years ago? How is it that these individuals I'm reading about live concurrently with me? There must have been some hope, some spark of agency, even after decades of totalitarian oppression, that people in my country, despite all their privileges, do not share.
The fact is that, even if the immediate causes are recent, this state of affairs is nothing new. Most peoples cannot rise to the occasion like the Romanians. They're not capable of it. Absent rare blips along a five-thousand-year timeline, they die like dogs under regimes they do not have the will or power to change, living for hundreds of years, grandparent to grandchild, under the same order.
That obituary is what awaits us, too, if we don't solve some nasty coordination problems. But I must confess that I have a competition in me. I don't want to be another statistic. I want to rid the world of this disgusting hopelessness that pervades every state on the globe, that has been invented and pushed on us by the people looting it for scraps of meaningless status. I want ours to be the generation that succeeded at avenging Liu Xiaobo, and Alexey Navalny, and Andrei Sakharov. More than anything else I want to give the common man his freedom back, to make him a part of history again and preserve this unique and precious heritage he inherited.
It feels like the common man lost a bit of his soul after we exterminated the vast majority of organized crime. Yes, crime sucks. But even if these organizations were horrible for the communities they preyed on, the existence of an underbelly at least suggested limits to state power. There was an existence proof of people outside the state developing a (conditional, fictional) code of honor, and coordinating amongst themselves, in a way that was transgressive and competitive with the state, unlike the drugged-out homeless man yelling obscenities at you on the subway. People watching old movies and TV shows can feel the guilty exhilaration at the idea of participating in or shaping a network outside the state, with its own rules.
Nowadays even the petty crime you do witness feels like evidence of the state's taunting indifference. There are cameras on every street corner; every child grows up with the tacit knowledge that everything they've ever said or done is going to be logged in some government database searchable by AI. The "government", whatever that means, could stop the guy who's shitting on the subway, if it wanted to. Crime has stopped being something that happens in spite of the government, or undermines it, and started being another boring reminder of your powerlessness in the face of the reigning regime, and of how nobody can ever do anything about it.
I don't even know if removing the new technology enforcing the law would do anything. Today most of the public is so passive and demoralized that if you try to die for a cause they immediately start making debased edits of the video. It's just a dark joke, they'll say. But I don't think that people felt compelled to joke about it when they felt like there was something they could do to change their situation, when they felt like there was some organization that could evolve out of the chaos without being parasitized by social media. I read about events like the Romanian Revolution and it feels like I'm reading a fantasy novel. How did this happen forty years ago? How is it that these individuals I'm reading about live concurrently with me? There must have been some hope, some spark of agency, even after decades of totalitarian oppression, that people in my country, despite all their privileges, do not share.
The fact is that, even if the immediate causes are recent, this state of affairs is nothing new. Most peoples cannot rise to the occasion like the Romanians. They're not capable of it. Absent rare blips along a five-thousand-year timeline, they die like dogs under regimes they do not have the will or power to change, living for hundreds of years, grandparent to grandchild, under the same order.
That obituary is what awaits us, too, if we don't solve some nasty coordination problems. But I must confess that I have a competition in me. I don't want to be another statistic. I want to rid the world of this disgusting hopelessness that pervades every state on the globe, that has been invented and pushed on us by the people looting it for scraps of meaningless status. I want ours to be the generation that succeeded at avenging Liu Xiaobo, and Alexey Navalny, and Andrei Sakharov. More than anything else I want to give the common man his freedom back, to make him a part of history again and preserve this unique and precious heritage he inherited.