The idea that Christianity is losing men because it’s too soft assumes that men are primarily drawn to rigid, militaristic, or hierarchical structures. However, church decline in the West is part of a much larger trend of secularization that affects both men and women. Societal shifts—such as declining birth rates, increased individualism, and skepticism toward organized religion—play a bigger role than the tone of worship services. The argument also assumes that Christianity was once a hyper-masculine faith that has now become too gentle. However, Jesus himself preached love, forgiveness, and humility. Early Christianity grew largely because it emphasized charity, inclusion, and community—values that aren’t inherently “feminine” but are fundamental to human relationships. The idea that faith must be "hardcore" to attract men misrepresents what Christianity has always been about.While some might argue that Islam and Eastern Orthodox Christianity are growing because of their structure, this ignores the role of birth rates and cultural retention in religious growth. Islam’s growth is largely due to high birth rates, not mass male conversions. Meanwhile, Orthodox Christianity isn’t rapidly expanding in the West but rather maintaining numbers in traditionally Orthodox countries. Furthermore, plenty of strict Protestant groups (like conservative evangelicalism) are also in decline, showing that rigidness alone doesn’t guarantee growth.
Blaming the decline of men in Protestant churches on being "too soft" is an oversimplification that ignores broader social, historical, and demographic trends. Christianity isn't failing men because it’s compassionate—it’s struggling because organized religion as a whole is shifting in the modern world. The real challenge isn't toughness, but making faith meaningful and relevant to people’s lives today.
I was raised Catholic, became agnostic around 13, stopped thinking an afterlife made sense at 15, and noticed I was no longer religious at 16.
But I still spent the next ~12 years in pretty close proximity to Christianity. I did religious studies at school, I studied philosophy and theology at university, and most importantly I sung in church choirs, which meant I was regularly attending services.
I also wasn't crazy about the label 'atheist', as I didn't think my beliefs had much in common with famous or 'new' atheists (Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, AC Grayling). I often found their objections uninteresting, as they dealt with claims concerning things like 'metaphysics' and 'theodicy' that most Christians I knew didn't really care about. For those Christians, religion was more of a spiritual commitment or a decision to live a certain way, and, for example, their conservative approach to romance seemed like it could be valid even if the Church couldn't explain why God lets evil exist.
But if what you're doing is following a set of practices that are at most loosely inferred from a set of community texts and a history of community tradition, why take the extra step of identifying as Christian? Why not just say 'hey there's some good stuff in here, and I'll join in with the good and leave the bad'? What makes you want to take that extra step?
During the last 12 years I've wondered if I wanted to take that extra step again, until this year, when I realized any desire I had to do so was based in meekness.
Meekness is praised in the Gospel:
Not to mention that in the most important story in the whole Bible, the Son of God gives himself up *for death* without putting up a fight. He knows he will be betrayed but he waits for his captors to come and arrest him.
Meekness is a big deal for Christianity. And it shouldn't be. Meekness is not a virtue.
In the dictionary definition of meekness above, 'quiet, gentle' sounds fine; 'easily imposed on' and 'submissive', not so much. Meekness is when you don't stand up and ask for what you need, or it is when you allow what you need to be taken from you. This is a disaster for your personal wellbeing, and perhaps even worse when it comes to looking out for your community.
One of my clearest memories of Catholic school is sitting at a breakfast table watching three kids bully a fourth. The fourth kid had recently returned from a suspension for writing something rude in a guest book; it was pretty clear he had been pressured if not coerced. As if the events happening in front of him weren't enough, the supervising adult at the table would have known all this. But he was very deliberately staring straight ahead and into the distance, focussing his energy on ignoring what was happening.
And if you think meekness is a virtue, why wouldn't you do what that adult did? If you actually value not standing up for yourself, what hope is there for the people around you who might be counting on you to stand up for them?
Unfortunately, Christian communities that break this pattern are in my experience the exception not the rule. We had Marthin Luther King Jr., but he also wrote the following in his Letter from Birmingham Jail:
Meekness.
Why did I wonder if I wanted to join the Church again? I realized I had been missing the sensation from childhood of being 'easily imposed upon, submissive', and letting a greater authority determine a larger part of what I believed.
The world is scary, and as a kid there's a lot of comfort in that kind of a relationship. I can't be the only one who was taken in by it.
But I'm not a kid any more, and as soon as I recognized the roots of what I was feeling, I also recognized it was neither healthy nor acceptable to me. Thanks, but no thanks, I'll be an impartial observer of religion from now on.
If you're reading this and you are a Christian, here are my challenges to you:
n.b. I've encountered the term 'protest atheism' which does a decent job of capturing where I am now. A new atheist like Dawkins would say 'God doesn't exist', whereas a protest atheist might say 'this isn't how we should live'.