"Besides that"? All you did was name a statement of a fairly obvious preference choice after one guy who happened to have it so that you could then drop it dismissively.
Wedrifid, not sure what to tell you. Bostrom is but one voice and his evolutionary analysis is very much flawed - again: detailed critique upcoming.
No, he mightn't care and I certainly don't. I am glad I am here but I have no particular loyalty to evolution because of that. I know for sure that evolution feels no such loyalty to me and would discard both me and my species in time if it remained the dominant force of development.
Evolution is not the dominant force of development on the human level by a long shot, but it still very much draws the line in the sand in regards to what you can and can not do if you want to stick around in the long run. You don't walk your 5'8'' of pink squishiness in front of a train for the exact same reason. And why don't you? Because not doing that is a necessary condition for your continued existence. What other conditions are there? Maybe there are some that are less obvious then simply stopping to breath, failing to eat and avoiding hard, fast, shiny things? How about at the level of culture? Could it possibly be, that there are some ideas that are more conducive to the continued existence of their believers than others?
“It must not be forgotten that although a high standard of morality gives but a slight or no advantage to each individual man and his children over the other men of the same tribe, yet that an advancement in the standard of morality and in increase in the number of well-endowed men will certainly give an immense advantage to one tribe over another. There can be no doubt that a tribe including many members who, from possessing in a high degree the spirit of patriotism, fidelity, obedienhce, courage, and sympathy, were always ready to give aid to each other and to sacrifice themselves for the common good, would be victorious over other tribes; and this would be natural selection.” (Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man, p. 166)
How long do you think you can ignore evolutionary dynamics and get away with it before you have to get over your inertia and will be forced to align yourself to them by the laws of nature or perish? Just because you live in a time of extraordinary freedoms afforded to you by modern technology and are thus not aware that your ancestors walked a very particular path that brought you into existence certainly has nothing to do with the fact that they most certainly did. You do not believe that doing any random thing will get you what you want - so what leads you to believe that your existence does not depend on you making sure you stay within a comfortable margin of certainty in regards to being naturally selected? You are right in one thing: you are assured the benign indifference of the universe should you fail to wise up. I however would find that to be a terrible waste.
Please do not patronize me by trying to claim you know what I understand and don't understand.
How long do you think you can ignore evolutionary dynamics and get away with it before you have to get over your inertia and will be forced to align yourself to them by the laws of nature or perish?
A literal answer was probably not what you were after but probably about 40 years, depending on when a general AI is created. After that it will not matter whether I conform my behaviour evolutionary dynamics as best I can or not. I will not be able to compete with a superintelligence no matter what I do. I'm just a glorified monkey. I can hold about 7 items ... (read more)
As promised, here is the "Q" part of the Less Wrong Video Q&A with Eliezer Yudkowsky.
The Rules
1) One question per comment (to allow voting to carry more information about people's preferences).
2) Try to be as clear and concise as possible. If your question can't be condensed to a few paragraphs, you should probably ask in a separate post. Make sure you have an actual question somewhere in there (you can bold it to make it easier to scan).
3) Eliezer hasn't been subpoenaed. He will simply ignore the questions he doesn't want to answer, even if they somehow received 3^^^3 votes.
4) If you reference certain things that are online in your question, provide a link.
5) This thread will be open to questions and votes for at least 7 days. After that, it is up to Eliezer to decide when the best time to film his answers will be. [Update: Today, November 18, marks the 7th day since this thread was posted. If you haven't already done so, now would be a good time to review the questions and vote for your favorites.]
Suggestions
Don't limit yourself to things that have been mentioned on OB/LW. I expect that this will be the majority of questions, but you shouldn't feel limited to these topics. I've always found that a wide variety of topics makes a Q&A more interesting. If you're uncertain, ask anyway and let the voting sort out the wheat from the chaff.
It's okay to attempt humor (but good luck, it's a tough crowd).
If a discussion breaks out about a question (f.ex. to ask for clarifications) and the original poster decides to modify the question, the top level comment should be updated with the modified question (make it easy to find your question, don't have the latest version buried in a long thread).
Update: Eliezer's video answers to 30 questions from this thread can be found here.