I like this post!

Some evidence that security mindset generalizes across at least some domains: the same white hat people who are good at finding exploits in things like kernels seem to also be quite good at finding exploits in things like web apps, real-world companies, and hardware. I don't have a specific person to give as an example, but this observation comes from going to a CTF competition and talking to some of the people who ran it about the crazy stuff they'd done that spanned a wide array of different areas.

Another slightly different example, Wei Dai is someone who I actually knew about outside of Less Wrong from his early work on cryptocurrency stuff, so he was at least at one point involved in a security-heavy community (I'm of the opinion that early cryptocurrency folks were on average much better about security mindset than the average current cryptocurrency community member). Based on his posts and comments, he generally strikes me as having security mindset style thinking from his comments and from my perspective has contributed a lot of good stuff to AI alignment.

Theo de Raadt is notoriously... opinionated, so it would definitely be interesting to see him thrown on an AI team. That said, I suspect someone like Ralph Merkle, who's a bona fide cryptography wizard (he invented public key cryptography and Merkle trees!) and is heavily involved in the cryonics and nanotech communities, could fairly easily get up to speed on AI control work and contribute from a unique security/cryptography-oriented perspective. In particular, now that there seems to be more alignment/control work that involves at least exploring issues with concrete proposals, I think someone like this would have less trouble finding ways to contribute. That said, having cryptography experience in addition to security experience does seem helpful. Cryptography people are probably more used to combining their security mindset with their math intuition than your average white-hat hacker.

Jimrandomh's Shortform

by jimrandomh 1 min read4th Jul 201964 comments

This post is a container for my short-form writing. See this post for meta-level discussion about shortform as an upcoming site feature.