I am tired of repeatedly seeing clever people explain on internet how one side of the political spectrum is consequentialist (which is apparently Latin for "smart"), while the other side is deontologist (which is apparently Latin for "dumb"). I mean, yes, this probably is how many smart people on the former side sincerely see it, from inside. Now if you would just step out of your bubble for a moment, and listen to the other side, you would find out that the smart people on the latter side actually see it as a conflict between short-term and long-term consequentialist-ish thinking. Indeed, the similarities between "consequentialist vs deontologist" and "short-term thinker vs long-term thinker" are scary. Consider this:
A: "Hey, while don't we all just do X? It is obviously a good thing!"
B: "Uh, we shouldn't do X, even if it seems nice at the first sight, because... <some long and complicated reasoning that doesn't sound convincing to A at all>."
Was this a consequentialist debating a deontologist? Or a short-term thinker debating a long-term thinker? The answer depends on which of these two people, A or B, do you ask. (Yeah, the fact that you asked A, and he confirmed that it actually was consequentialist vs deontologist, doesn't sound to me as convincing as it probably does to you. Sorry.)
And no, I am not arguing here that B is right. I am saying different people will provide different interpretations of the same situation. And guess what: each side is going to frame the situation in a way that makes them the smart ones. The fact that you hear certain interpretation more frequently is simply a reflection of which people you interact more with.
Similarly, I am frustrated with people saying how "guess culture" is bad, and people shouldn't be expected to guess things correctly. Again, this doesn't mean I disagree; I just think there is a trade-off, and things are less obvious than they seem. There are two kinds of people who prefer to debate things explicitly, for different reasons; as an exaggeration let's call them autists and psychopaths.
Autists prefer explicit communication because they suck at guessing; that's legitimate complaint. Psychopaths prefer explicit communication because it allows them to find loopholes, abuse people, and then say: "heh, your fault, you didn't explicitly communicate your expectation that I wouldn't do X" and have their behavior socially accepted (because everyone who cannot flawlessly communicate their extrapolated volition deserves to be converted to paperclips).
When you establish the "tell culture", expect a lot of happy autists, and a lot of abusive assholes. I am not saying whether the trade-off is worth it, or not. I am just saying, don't be surprised when the assholes come. Because they will. And then, either your community will fall apart, or you will gradually invent some new rules to protect yourselves... the rules that other people will now criticize as arbitrary, irrational, and preventing optimal communication.
Guess culture rules can be abused by assholes as well.
If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post, then it goes here.
Notes for future OT posters:
1. Please add the 'open_thread' tag.
2. Check if there is an active Open Thread before posting a new one. (Immediately before; refresh the list-of-threads page before posting.)
3. Open Threads should start on Monday, and end on Sunday.
4. Unflag the two options "Notify me of new top level comments on this article" and "