I don't think that explicit communications automatically leads to more abuse.
It doesn't lead to more abuse among people who didn't want to abuse others in the first place. But for people who already wanted to abuse others, this creates additional plausible deniability; it allows them to shift the blame to the victim: "hey, I never promised not to do X, and they never asked me not to do X, so it's okay by the rules of your group, right?", where X is some rare ugly behavior that you automatically expect nice people not to do, but it doesn't come to your mind when you explicitly negotiate the boundaries.
To make an analogy; in legal situations it is somewhat expected that people cannot make perfect contracts, so there are two helps. First, the law provides "templates" for your contracts; you start your contract by saying "this is a contract based on law X" which means that the law X provides defaults in case something unexpected happens. For example, you make a contract with me that you will pay me €10 today, and tomorrow I will mow your lawn. I take the money and spend them on beer, then get hit by a car and die. What now? Are my relatives required to return you the money? Can they keep the money and mow your lawn instead of me, even if they are e.g. much worse lawnmowers? Or are you simply supposed to accept the loss? Our mutual agreement didn't include this possibility, because neither of us expected it. (That's the weakness of the "tell culture": anything you forget to mention explicitly is undefined.) In legal situations, basing our contract on law X means that for weird situations we didn't mention explicitly, there is a chance the law X provides an answer. (Analogically, in the "guess culture", all relations are automatically based on the cultural expectations.)
Second, in legal system some laws can override contracts. Libertarians sometimes complain about it, but the idea is that if you sign a 200-page agreement with e.g. your phone company, they cannot in the long and barely legible text cleverly hide a clause that e.g. if you are late at payment, you become their slave. Sorry, the constitution says slavery is illegal, the part of the contract is automatically invalid. This prevents abuse in situations where you deal with someone who is either much better than you at law generally, or can spend more computing power constructing the specific contract than you can spend analyzing it. This prevents you from being exploited too much by people with more computing power.
I think that in real life, no matter how much "tell culture" is our applause light, we actually hold a lot of unspoken assumptions. To give a sex-related example, if one party says "okay, let's have sex, but only with a condom", it is automatically assumed that the other party didn't intentionally pierce the condom, even if such assumption is never communicated explicitly (and I'd bet it almost never is), and it would be quite reasonable to blame the party that pierced the condom, even if they could defend themselves that technically they followed the rules of the "tell culture" to the letter.
For example, you make a contract with me that you will pay me €10 today, and tomorrow I will mow your lawn. I take the money and spend them on beer, then get hit by a car and die. What now? Are my relatives required to return you the money? Can they keep the money and mow your lawn instead of me, even if they are e.g. much worse lawnmowers? Or are you simply supposed to accept the loss?
(Not really on topic, but FWIW my intuition tells me that the person who was driving the car that killed you now owes me €10 or however much is needed for me to hire so... (read more)
If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post, then it goes here.
Notes for future OT posters:
1. Please add the 'open_thread' tag.
2. Check if there is an active Open Thread before posting a new one. (Immediately before; refresh the list-of-threads page before posting.)
3. Open Threads should start on Monday, and end on Sunday.
4. Unflag the two options "Notify me of new top level comments on this article" and "