At this point, looking up to Tolkien seems like a likely result of the Halo Effect. His quotes make him seem way too overconfident in his philosophically dubious worldviews. I think I have a lot more respect for any random rationalist blogger than one who is that sure of himself but obviously wrong in some examples that are clear to us.
What do you mean lacking context? My context is judgement of character in absolute terms, which indeed favors more modern people. You are demanding us to switch to a context where we judge him relative to experiences of not only his time, but his personal circumstances, which is much more subjective. I don't like how you're switching context but accusing me of not using context.
All quotes, unless otherwise marked, are Tolkien's words as printed in The Letters of J.R.R.Tolkien: Revised and Expanded Edition. All emphases mine.
Machinery is Power is Evil
Writing to his son Michael in the RAF:
The Sam Butler reference is to Samuel Butler's Erewhon, a science fiction novel which is the first known work to warn about self-replicating machines and the possibility of machine consciousness. The 'Butlerian Jihad' from Dune is another famous reference to Butler. A quote from Erewhon:
Tolkien again, writing to his son Christopher during the war:
And as the war seems to be ending, he writes:
On Atomic Bombs
On Magic and Machines
Again from his letter to Milton Waldman, the one place Tolkien deigns to explain, or perhaps to 'rationalize', the underlying theory behind his work:
elsewhere he says, of the Lord of the Rings in particular
The Ring as externalized power
Impatience as the root of evil
Altruism as the root of evil
And as an extreme case:
Sauron as metaphor for the evil of 'reformers' and 'science'
On Language
The straightjacket of Modern English
This next passage, from a letter to a reader critiquing the archaic English spoken by the Riders of Rohan, really helped me understand Tolkien's obsession with language. It vividly shows how he felt the chains of modern English, how constrained it is and how little it can express:
It reminds me of the feeling I had when I started to read Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment in English translation when he was assigned me for a literature course. I had never read him in Russian; but I could just feel the words were wrong. I dug up a Russian copy at the university library, and wrote my term essay on Dostoyevsky's use of the word podlost, a word without translation in English but crucial to understanding Raskolnikov's self-image; and I've been much more skeptical of translations ever since.
Philology is philosophy, because it lets you escape the trap of the language you were born with. Much like mathematics, humanity's most ambitious such escape attempt, still very much in its infancy.
If you really want to express the truth about what you feel and see, you need to be inventing new languages. And if you want to preserve a culture, you must not lose its language.
Argent and Silver
On being criticized for using the word 'argent' in place of 'silver' in a book of poems:
A Fallen World
His worldview is suffused, more than any writer I know, with the sense of the The Fall. All problems blamed on the fall. Again,
almost like a tic, a way of excusing it. if you say a bad thing the narrative demands you explain it somehow, otherwise it would be blaspheme God's good name - so you say it is because we are fallen, put the blame back on humanity, or perhaps on the Serpent that tempted us.
Elaborating on his theology of Eden and the Fall in a letter to his son Christopher:
He continues by constrasting this sense of the Fall with more ordinary human tragedy:
hearing it described this way makes me realize this heart-racking was the emotion that first drew me to Tolkien's works. Not the ordinary tragedy of the hobbits, but the sense of deep sad memory, a vanished past, a world of yesterday.
"Gandalf's words about the Palantír" refers to this passage, Gandalf speaking to Pippin as they ride to Gondor:
but to me this feeling is best evoked by the words of Galadriel as the Fellowship departs Lorién:
Yet this attitude of nostalgia and sadness can go too far even for Tolkien:
All stories are about the Fall
From Tolkien's letter to Milton Waldman:
On his mother
Love, Marriage, and Sexuality
Courtly Love
Dante's love for Beatrice is of this form. In one of his last letters, Tolkien gives an anti-example:
Women's exceptional attunement
Men are polygamous; Christian marriage is self-denial
'Soulmates' are exceedingly rare:
although later he does refer to his wife as his Luthién, and writes this hauntingly beautiful passage about their relationship:
Sex as source of disorder
Honesty is best
On the Second World War
On Hitler
Tolkien feels a special hatred of Hitler, precisely because they agree on the uniqueness of the 'noble northern spirit':
On aerial bombardment
Writing to his son, a pilot in the Royal Air Force:
Presumably the 'Orcs on our side' refers to the Soviet Union.
On British communist-sympathizers, and the U.S.A as Saruman
Why he wrote the Legendarium
To express his feelings about the first World War
Writing to his son during the Second World War:
Because nobody else was writing the kinds of stories he wanted to read
On receiving a letter from a young fan:
I thought these extracts from a letter I got yesterday would amuse you. I find these letters which I still occasionally get (apart from the smell of incense which fallen man can never quite fail to savour) make me rather sad. What thousands of grains of good human corn must fall on barren stony ground, if such a very small drop of water should be so intoxicating! But I suppose one should be grateful for the grace and fortune that have allowed me to provide even the drop.
And in one of his last letters:
To give England an epic of its own
To share a feeling of eucatastrophe
Against IQ tests
On Religion
Two interpretations of Tom Bombadil
Bombadil as Pacifist
Bombadil as Scientist
Note the contrast of "real" natural science with the power-hungry, machine-loving "scientists" Tolkien criticizes elsewhere.
On Hobbies
On Journeys
Though Tolkien set out to write a legendarium, the stories he is most famous for are journeys. The sense of adventure in Bilbo's walking song has stayed with me longer than any other song from the Lord of the Rings:
So I was glad to see him pontificate on the effects of journeys in his letters:
On Torture
Against the State-God
Against America
In all the letters he doesn't seem to have a single positive thing to say about America. From criticizing Disney to calling America "Saruman" to snide remarks about his American publishers... this is perhaps his most damning indictment:
Against Democracy
On Money, Art, and Duty
Something I didn't expect from the letters is a constant sense of financial pressure, a tenseness. A resentment of 'examination' - the task he spent 17 years of vacations on, in order to make a bit of extra money for medical care and his children's education. And a consequent willingness to trade off the purity of his vision.
An excerpt from a letter sent on receiving the script of an American Lord of the Rings adaptation:
And several years later:
Writing to his son:
On Death
Despite the emphasis on power and domination and machines early on, in later letters Tolkien starts to emphasize a different theme:
On Children's Literature
Tolkien is viscerally against it; deeply hates Disney and dislikes Hans Christian Andersen; and regretted compromising with its tropes in his writing of The Hobbit.
In Reluctant Support of Universities
Against being Photographed
(from a letter to Time-Life International)