That's not either/or. Plenty of participants here are quietly religious (I don't recall what the last survey said), yet they like the site for what it has to offer. It may well happen some day that some of the sequence posts will click in a way that would make you want to decide to distance yourself from your fellow saints. Or it might not. If you find some discussion topics which interest you more, then just enjoy those. As I mentioned originally, pure logical discourse is rarely the way to change deep-seated opinions and preferences. Those evolve as your subconscious mind integrates new ideas and experiences.
Yes, that's what I think I'll do. But many people here seem to be telling me that's impossible without some sort of cognitive dissonance. I don't think so.
If it's worth saying, but not worth its own post (even in Discussion), then it goes here.