515

LESSWRONG
LW

514
World Modeling
Personal Blog

16

[ Question ]

How much should I worry about the Atlanta Fed's GDP estimates?

by Brendan Long
4th Mar 2025
1 min read
A
2
2

16

World Modeling
Personal Blog

16

How much should I worry about the Atlanta Fed's GDP estimates?
5Anon User
2Brendan Long
New Answer
New Comment

2 Answers sorted by
top scoring

Anon User

Mar 04, 2025

50

This looks to be primarily about imports - that is, primarily taking into account Trump's new tariffs. I am guessing that Wall Street does not quite believe that Trump actually means it...

Add Comment

Brendan Long

Mar 05, 2025

20

This economist thinks the reason is that inputs were up in January and the calculation is treating that as less domestic production rather than increased inventories:

OK, so what can we say about the current forecast of -2.8% for Q1 of 2025? First, almost all of the data in the model right now are for January 2025 only. We still have 2 full months in the quarter to go (in terms of data collection). Second, the biggest contributor to the negative reading is a massive increase in imports in January 2025.

[...]

The Atlanta Fed GDPNow model is doing exactly that, subtracting imports. However, it’s likely they are doing it incorrectly. Those imports have to show up elsewhere in the GDP equation. They will either be current consumption, or added to business inventories (to be consumed in the future). My guess, without knowing the details of their model, is that it’s not picking up the change in either inventories or consumption that must result from the increased imports.

https://economistwritingeveryday.com/2025/03/05/understanding-the-projected-gdp-decline/

Add Comment
Moderation Log
More from Brendan Long
View more
Curated and popular this week
A
2
0

The Atlanta Fed is seemingly predicting -2.8% GDP growth in the first quarter of 2025.

I've seen several people mention this on Twitter, but it doesn't seem to be discussed much beyond that, and the stock market seems pretty normal (S&P 500 down 2% in the last month).

Is this not really a useful signal? Or is the market under-reacting?