but the pulse I got was like, exclusivism is waning, it's losing popularity very fast, and pluralism is on the rise.
My read, from my very limited perspective mostly engaging with new-age folks, and my serious-Christian highschool peers, as a teenager, is that this is mostly a response to increased secularism and waning traditional religious influence.
Enlightenment, post-Westphalian norms are very heavy on freedom of religion. As the influence of religions has waned, and societal mores have come to rest more and more on the secular morality. As an example, compare how in the 1950s, the question of whether someone "a good person" was loaded on whether they were an upstanding christian, and in 2010, the question of whether someone is "a good person" is much more highly loaded on whether they're racist.
In that process, insisting on religious exclusivism has become kind of goshe—it makes you seem like a backwards, bigoted, not-very cosmopolitan, person.
So how can religions respond? They can double down on calling out how mainstream society is sinful and try to fight the culture war. Or they can get with the program, and become hip and liberal, which means being accepting of other religions, to the point of saying that they're all paths up the same mountain, in defiance of centuries of doctrine and literal bloody violence.
And in practice, different religious communities have taken either one or some combination of these paths.
But this doesn't represent an awakening to the underlying metaphysical truth underlying all religions (which again, I'm much more sympathetic to than many). It mostly represents, religious institutions adapting to the pressures of modernity and secularism.
It looks to me like mostly a watering down of religion, rather than an expression of some deep spiritual impulse.
It's basically the same situation as regards doctrine on evolution by natural selection. The church fought that one, tooth and nail, for centuries, declaring that it was an outright. But secular culture eventually (mostly) beat the church in that culture war, and only now, to stay relevant, does the church backslide putting forward much weaker versions of their earlier position, whereby evolution is real, but compatible with divine creation. It's confused to look at that situation and attribute it to the Church's orientation to religion, all along, being more correct than we gave it credit for.
And the sociology matters here because makes different predictions about what will accelerate and increase this trend. If I'm correct, and this shift is mostly downstream of religions losing their influence, compared broader secular mores and values, then we won't get more of it by increasing the importance, salience, of religion.
Granted, I'll give you that much of the world is still religious, and maybe the best way to bridge to them to produce the transformations the world needs, is through their religion. But I think you're overstating how much religious pluralism is a force on the rise, as opposed to a kind of weak-sauce reaction to external forces.
And FWIW, there's something cruxy for me here. I would be more interested in religions if I thought that there was a positive rising force of religious pluralism (especially one that was grounded in the mystical traditions of the various religions), instead of reactive one.
Introduction from Ben
Zhukeepa is a LessWronger who I respect and whose views I'm interested in. In 2018 he wrote the first broadly successful explication of Paul Christiano's research ideas for AI alignment, has spent a lot of time interviewing people in AI about their perspectives, and written some more about neuroscience and agent foundations research. He came first in the 2012 US Math Olympiad, and formerly worked on a startup called AlphaSheets that raised many millions of dollars and then got acquihired by Google.
He has also gone around saying (in my opinion) pretty silly-sounding things like he believes in his steelman of the Second Coming of Christ. He also extols the virtues of various psychedelics, and has done a lot of circling and meditation. As a person who thinks most religions are pretty bad for the world and would like to see them die, and thinks many people trick themselves into false insights with spiritual and psychological practices like those Alex has explored, I was interested in knowing what this meant to him and why he was interested in it, and get a better sense of whether there's any value here or just distraction.
So we sat down for four 2-hour conversations over the course of four weeks, either written or transcribed, and have published them here as an extended LessWrong dialogue.
I think of this as being more of an interview about Zhukeepa's perspective, with me learning and poking at various parts of it. While I found it interesting throughout, this is a meandering conversation that many may prefer to skip unless they too are especially curious about Zhukeepa's perspective or have a particular interest in the topics discussed. You can skim through the table of contents on the left to get a sense of the discussion, and also read Zhu's introductory thoughts immediately below.
Introduction from Alex
Despite the warnings and admonishments against doing so, I’d decided 5 years ago to venture off to the Dangerous Foreign Land of Religion and Spirituality, after becoming convinced that something in that land was crucial for thinking clearly about AI alignment and AI coordination. Since embarking on that journey, I’ve picked up a lot of customs and perspectives that the locals here on LessWrong are highly suspicious of.
A few months ago, I caught up with my old friend Ben Pace on a walk, who expressed a lot of skepticism toward my views, but nevertheless remained kind, patient, respectful, and curious about understanding where I was coming from. He also seemed to have a lot of natural aptitude in making sense of my views. This gave me hope that:
… which is what motivated me to begin an extended series of dialogues with him. Below are a couple of excerpts going into some points that I'm particularly glad surfaced over the course of this dialogue:
[...]
[...]
I also managed to clarify a couple of my core beliefs over the course of this dialogue, that I'd like to summarize here:
Conversation 1 — April 6th 2024
Alex and Ben had gone on a walk to discuss religion, and decided to continue the discussion over a LessWrong dialogue.
Alex's steelman of the Second Coming of Christ
Why is Alex interested in religions in the first place?
What has Alex gotten from religion?
Resentment, forgiveness, and acceptance
Conversation 2 – April 13th 2024
At the next meeting we recorded audio and had it transcribed, and then lightly edited. This was 2 hours, and Ben was quite underslept.
What Alex gets from religious stories
Orientation toward death
What useful things do old religious stories have to say about how to live life well today?
Forgiving yourself, and devoting your life to something
Changing the minds of all of humanity / steel-Arbital
How Alex thinks about changing the world
Coordinating with the rest of the world sounds annoying
Maybe religious pluralists are sane?
<bathroom break>
A mathematical synthesis of religious metaphysics?
Conversation 3 — April 20th, 2024
We continued our dialogue over Zoom on April 20th 2024. The audio was also transcribed and lightly edited.
On the nature of evil
Religious prophets vs the Comet King on the problem of evil
(Spoilers for UNSONG below.)
Evil is like cancer, maybe
Mistake vs conflict theory on cancer / evil
Forgiving evil in ourselves
Does mistake theory toward sociopaths really make sense?
Rescuing old religions vs competing with old religions
Alex doesn't personally find institutionalized religion compelling
Mistake vs conflict theory toward existing religions
Religious pluralism coalition memetically outcompeting religious exclusivism
Why Alex doesn't want to start a new religion
Does the "Allah will protect me" story suck?
Jesus's empirical claim about evil
Alex doesn't want to tell people how to live
In closing
Conversation 4 — April 28th 2024
We continued our dialogue over Zoom on April 20th 2024. The audio was also transcribed and lightly edited.
Intro
Apparently: Agent Foundations = Religious Metaphysics = SteelArbital
Is Steel-Arbital harder than coordinating around not building AGI?
Steel-Arbital as a preference synthesizer
Killing Moloch with a decentralized singleton running on Steel-Arbital
(What would you do with a trusted preference synthesizer?)
Steel-Arbital should reveal and forgive blind spots
Religion as a tool for coordinating with the masses
Steel-Arbital vs religious visions for a fixed world
What religions say about starting new religions
Revisiting agent foundations vs religious metaphysics vs steel-Arbital
Cruxes around coordinating with the masses
Ben finally gets why Zhu doesn't want to start a new religion
Going forward